Navy Shipyards
U.S. Navy Shipyards: Asbestos Exposure Across the Nine Principal Naval Yards
Executive Summary
The U.S. Navy operated nine principal government-owned shipyards through the era of heavy asbestos use — a network of construction, repair, overhaul, and decommissioning facilities that built and maintained the Atlantic, Pacific, and submarine fleets from the 18th century through the late Cold War. Across these yards — Puget Sound (Bremerton, WA), Norfolk (Portsmouth, VA), Boston (Charlestown, MA), Pearl Harbor (Oahu, HI), Mare Island (Vallejo, CA), Philadelphia (Philadelphia, PA), Portsmouth (Kittery, ME), Long Beach (Long Beach, CA), and Brooklyn (New York, NY) — over 300 documented asbestos-containing products were used in vessel construction and repair, exposing hundreds of thousands of civilian and military workers between the 1930s and the early 1980s.[4][5]
Mesothelioma latency from first asbestos exposure runs 20 to 60 years, which means diagnoses tied to Navy-yard work in the 1940s through the 1970s continued to emerge into the 2020s.[6] In a Pearl Harbor shipyard cohort, mesothelioma incidence among Hawaii residents in 1977–1982 was 67.3 per million men per year, against 5.8 for the state as a whole.[7] In a U.S. Coast Guard shipyard cohort, the men had significantly increased mortality from mesothelioma and lung cancer.[8] (For the full standardized mortality ratio (SMR) data set across yard trades, see Shipyard_Workers.)
Compensation pathways differ for civilian and uniformed yard workers. Civilian shipyard workers — pipefitters, insulators, boilermakers, electricians, machinists, riggers — are typically covered by the federal Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act and may also pursue asbestos trust fund claims and product-liability lawsuits against the manufacturers that supplied the Navy.[9] Active-duty and veteran personnel pursue VA disability compensation through the M21-1 nexus process — mesothelioma is not a PACT Act presumptive condition, so veterans must document in-service asbestos exposure and obtain a physician's medical nexus opinion connecting the diagnosis to their service — plus parallel trust fund and lawsuit recoveries.[10] The 2026 VA disability rate at 100% is $3,938.58 per month for a veteran with no dependents.[11][12][13][14]
At a Glance
- Nine principal yards — Government-owned U.S. Navy construction and repair facilities: Puget Sound, Norfolk, Boston, Pearl Harbor, Mare Island, Philadelphia, Portsmouth (Kittery, ME), Long Beach, and Brooklyn. Four are still active (Puget Sound, Norfolk, Pearl Harbor, Portsmouth); five are closed or repurposed.
- Asbestos throughout the ship — Pipe insulation, boiler lagging, gaskets, packing, deck tile, sprayed fireproofing, electrical insulation, valve components, and bulkhead panels were standard across every yard from the 1930s through the early 1980s.[5]
- Pearl Harbor mesothelioma incidence far above the statewide rate — Seven mesotheliomas occurred in 1977–1982 among 7,029 Hawaii residents in a Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard cohort, an incidence of 67.3 per million men per year against 5.8 for the state as a whole.[7]
- Coast Guard yard cohort confirms excess mortality — In a retrospective cohort of 4,702 civilian workers at the Coast Guard shipyard in Baltimore, the men had a standardized mortality ratio (SMR) of 5.07 for mesothelioma (95% CI 1.85–11.03) and a significant excess of lung cancer.[8]
- 20- to 60-year latency to diagnosis — Workers exposed during the WWII shipbuilding surge began developing mesothelioma in the 1970s; the FRAM-modernization cohort (1950s–1960s) is still being diagnosed today.[6]
- FRAM program drove sustained exposure into the 1960s — The Navy's Fleet Rehabilitation and Modernization program extended the service life of WWII-era destroyers by stripping and replacing asbestos insulation, a process that disturbed legacy materials yard-wide.
- Civilian and military pathways run on separate tracks — with one important exception — Asbestos trust funds, product-liability lawsuits, and (for veterans) VA disability established through the M21-1 nexus process can be pursued in parallel; VA compensation is not reduced by a tort or trust recovery, while whether a trust payment reduces a civil verdict depends on the jurisdiction's setoff rule.[10] LHWCA federal workers' compensation is different: it is expressly subject to the offset provision of 33 U.S.C. § 933(f), and § 933(g) terminates all compensation and medical benefits where a third-party settlement is made without the required written approvals — from the employer, the employer's carrier, and the person entitled to compensation — or without notice.[15][9]
- 2026 monthly VA rate at 100% disability is $3,938.58 — mesothelioma is not a PACT Act presumptive condition, but once service connection is established through the M21-1 nexus process, veterans typically qualify at the 100% rating.[11][12][13][14]
Key Facts
| Metric | Finding |
|---|---|
| Yards in this hub | 9 principal government-owned U.S. Navy shipyards |
| Currently active yards | 4 (Puget Sound, Norfolk, Pearl Harbor, Portsmouth/Kittery) |
| Closed/repurposed yards | 5 (Boston/Charlestown, Mare Island, Philadelphia, Long Beach, Brooklyn) |
| Heaviest asbestos use period | 1939 through early 1980s |
| Pearl Harbor mesothelioma incidence | 67.3 per million men per year, 1977–1982, Hawaii-resident subset (vs. 5.8 statewide)[7] |
| Coast Guard yard SMR (mesothelioma) | 5.07 (95% CI 1.85–11.03)[8] |
| OSHA shipyard standard | 29 CFR 1915.1001 (PEL 0.1 f/cc 8-hr TWA)[5] |
| Latency to diagnosis | 20 to 60 years from first exposure[6] |
| 2026 VA 100% rate (no dependents) | $3,938.58 per month[11] |
| Asbestos trust funds available | $36.8 billion across 60 trusts (2011, at funding)[3] |
Why Did the U.S. Navy Use So Much Asbestos in Its Shipyards?
The Navy specified asbestos use in submarines beginning in 1922 and progressively expanded the requirement through dozens of military specifications (MIL-SPECs) covering thermal insulation, gaskets, packing, fireproofing, deck coverings, and electrical components.[5] By the 1939 mobilization for World War II, the federal government had classified asbestos as a critical material and begun stockpiling chrysotile and amosite for naval and merchant shipbuilding. The 1942 Asbestos Conservation Order banned non-military uses to prioritize the mineral for ship construction.
Three engineering pressures drove the demand. First, asbestos provided thermal insulation that could withstand the high-temperature steam systems essential to a steam-turbine fleet. Second, naval combat-survivability requirements called for compartmentalized fire barriers, and asbestos was the cheapest mass-produced flame-resistant fiber. Third, asbestos packing and gaskets sealed pressure systems against vibration in a way that synthetic alternatives of the era could not match. The result was that virtually every space on a 1940s through 1970s Navy vessel — engine room, boiler room, fire room, magazine, berthing compartment, mess deck, electrical panel — contained asbestos.
For yard workers, this translated into ubiquitous exposure. Every overhaul, every battle-damage repair, every modernization, every decommissioning required cutting, ripping, sanding, or replacing asbestos materials. Confined below-deck spaces with limited ventilation amplified airborne fiber concentrations to levels that industrial-hygiene measurements taken decades later documented at 5 to 100 fibers per cubic centimeter — between 50 and 1,000 times the 0.1 f/cc 8-hour permissible exposure limit later set under OSHA 29 CFR 1915.1001.[5]
Federal specifications for subsidized ships eliminated asbestos lagging and insulation in 1978, but ships delivered before 1975 still contain extensive asbestos materials. Vessels delivered between 1975 and 1978 contain asbestos in the form of insulating cement on machinery casings. OSHA accordingly mandates that any pre-1980 vessel be presumed to contain asbestos for purposes of repair, maintenance, or demolition work.[5]
The Nine Principal U.S. Navy Shipyards
The yards profiled below are the nine government-owned facilities most central to U.S. Navy construction and repair during the heavy-asbestos era. Each has its own dedicated wiki page covering yard-specific litigation, ship construction lists, environmental remediation, and worker testimony; the summaries here are the hub overview only.
Puget Sound Naval Shipyard (Bremerton, Washington)
Puget Sound Naval Shipyard was established in 1891 and remains the Pacific Northwest's largest naval shore facility. Tens of thousands of civilian and military workers serviced surface combatants, carriers, and (in the post-WWII era) nuclear submarines through the heavy-asbestos period. A 1970 U.S. Navy occupational health survey of yard pipe coverers and insulators found that 21 percent had pulmonary findings consistent with asbestos exposure — an early internal Navy acknowledgment of the scale of the problem. Industrial-hygiene reviews covering 1962 through 1972 documented extremely high airborne fiber concentrations during WWII and Korean-War-era operations.
EPA cleanup actions identified asbestos, mercury, lead, and other contaminants on shipyard grounds and in surrounding waters. The yard remains active and continues to perform major nuclear-submarine maintenance; legacy asbestos persists in older structures and in vessels arriving for decommissioning. Documented worker lawsuits target the asbestos manufacturers (Johns-Manville, Raymark, and others) that supplied the yard rather than the Navy itself.
Norfolk Naval Shipyard (Portsmouth, Virginia)
Norfolk Naval Shipyard is the oldest continuously operated shipyard in the United States, with operations dating to 1767, and EPA's National Priorities List site narrative lists asbestos among the wastes the yard generated.[16]
Litigation arising out of Norfolk has produced significant verdicts. A boilermaker employed at the yard in 1969 and through the 1970s reached settlement against asbestos product manufacturers after his mesothelioma diagnosis. In a separate pipe-coverer case, manufacturers including Johns-Manville settled and then attempted to shift liability to the Navy; the court ruled the manufacturers remained liable for failure-to-warn — a precedent cited across naval-yard cases. The yard remains active and continues to overhaul Atlantic Fleet vessels under modern OSHA controls.
Boston Naval Shipyard / Charlestown Navy Yard (Charlestown, Massachusetts)
The Boston Naval Shipyard, originally the Charlestown Navy Yard, opened in 1800 and built, repaired, modernized, and resupplied ships for 174 years before closing in 1974.[17]
Asbestos use spanned the 1920s through the 1980s. Notably, Navy medical officers at the yard were already recommending safety controls for asbestos handling in 1939 — well before the wartime expansion — but use continued and grew. Modern litigation includes McIsaac v. Air & Liquid Systems Corp. (2019), brought after a rigger's 2019 mesothelioma death, settled out of court, and Hovsepian v. Crane Co. (2012), filed by a marine machinist who worked at the yard 1958–1964. The site is now divided between the Boston National Historical Park (which preserves USS Constitution and the museum ship USS Cassin Young), residential and commercial development, and educational/medical institutions including the MGH Institute of Health Professions and Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital. The Charlestown Navy Yard is classified as a Formerly Used Defense Site (FUDS); cleanup spending has totaled $13.7 million with $6.13 million in additional work expected.[18]
Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard (Pearl Harbor, Hawaii)
Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard was authorized in 1908 and became the Pacific Fleet's principal repair facility after December 7, 1941. A retrospective cohort of 7,971 male yard workers was followed for up to 29 years; among the 7,029 Hawaii residents in it, seven mesotheliomas occurred in 1977–1982, an incidence of 67.3 per million men per year against 5.8 for the state as a whole.[7] The study concluded that the long-term relative risk for mesothelioma may exceed that for bronchogenic lung cancer.[7]
The 12,600-acre Pearl Harbor Naval Complex is an EPA Superfund site, with remediation actions identified at hundreds of facilities. The yard remains active with approximately 6,300 employees and a roughly $1 billion annual economic impact, but the latency-driven case load from earlier exposure decades continues. Hawaii courts have recognized take-home (secondary) exposure liability, including awards to family members who developed mesothelioma after laundering asbestos-contaminated work clothes.
Mare Island Naval Shipyard (Vallejo, California)
Mare Island Naval Shipyard was established in 1854 as the Navy's first West Coast facility. WWII peak employment reached approximately 46,000 workers, who built and overhauled surface combatants, submarines (including a substantial fraction of the WWII-era U.S. submarine fleet), and Cold War-era nuclear submarines. The yard closed in 1996 under the Defense Base Closure and Realignment (BRAC) process; the site has since been redeveloped for mixed industrial, commercial, and residential use, with ongoing environmental remediation overseen by the Navy and the California Department of Toxic Substances Control.
Mare Island workers — pipefitters, insulators, boilermakers, electricians, machinists, and riggers — are heavily represented in California asbestos litigation. The yard's submarine work in particular generated extreme confined-space exposure, because submarine compartments concentrated airborne fibers far above surface-ship levels.
Philadelphia Naval Shipyard (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)
Philadelphia Naval Shipyard traced its origins to a 1776 yard at Front Street and Federal Street, with a permanent League Island facility commissioned in 1876. The yard was one of the principal Atlantic-side construction and repair facilities through both World Wars and the Cold War, building battleships, cruisers, and aircraft carriers and modernizing destroyers under the FRAM program. The Navy closed the yard in 1996; portions of the site continue to operate as a private-sector ship repair and naval-vessel layberth facility (the "Philadelphia Naval Business Center"), and the Inactive Ships Maintenance Office still uses parts of the property to maintain decommissioned vessels.
Philadelphia's high-volume modernization work — particularly the FRAM-program rework that disturbed legacy WWII insulation — produced a sustained second wave of asbestos exposure into the 1960s. Litigation arising out of Philadelphia involves the same product-manufacturer defendants seen across the network: Johns-Manville, Owens Corning, Pittsburgh Corning, Eagle-Picher, Garlock, and others.
Portsmouth Naval Shipyard (Kittery, Maine)
Portsmouth Naval Shipyard — located on Seavey Island in Kittery, Maine, despite its New Hampshire-port name — was established in 1800 as the Navy's first government-owned shipyard. It is the Navy's specialized facility for nuclear-submarine overhaul and is still active. Through the heavy-asbestos era it built and overhauled diesel-electric and nuclear submarines whose tightly compartmentalized engineering spaces produced some of the highest fiber concentrations in the network.
Portsmouth's submarine focus is significant for litigation purposes because submariners and yard workers servicing submarine compartments faced confined-space amplification of airborne asbestos. Submarine classes overhauled at Portsmouth — Gato, Balao, Tench, Skipjack, Permit/Thresher, Sturgeon, and Los Angeles — are all on the Navy's documented heavy-asbestos list.
Long Beach Naval Shipyard (Long Beach, California)
Long Beach Naval Shipyard opened in 1943 as Terminal Island Naval Shipyard. It was inactivated in June 1950, reactivated in January 1951 for the Korean War, and operated as a non-nuclear surface-ship overhaul facility for the Southern California fleet. At its Vietnam-era peak (1965–1970), 140 ships and 40,000 personnel were homeported at Long Beach. The yard closed in 1997 under BRAC.
A 1979 Comptroller General report focused specifically on asbestos contamination at Long Beach, documenting asbestos dust aboard two ships, stray fibers on pipes stripped of asbestos insulation, and pipe ends with exposed asbestos materials in a vessel's fire room. A January 2010 Navy cleanup report covered asbestos plus chemicals from storage, ship-manufacturing waste, degreasing agents, and other contaminants. The site has been converted to commercial container-port operations under the Port of Long Beach. A NIOSH cancer cohort study of Long Beach workers found excess mortality and incidence of mesothelioma, lung cancer, and colorectal cancer across all three asbestos exposure groups studied.
Brooklyn Navy Yard (Brooklyn, New York)
The Brooklyn Navy Yard (officially New York Naval Shipyard) was established in 1801; some 70,000 people worked there at its World War II peak, and it remained in continuous operation until 1966.[1] The site is now operated as the Brooklyn Navy Yard Development Corporation industrial park.
Brooklyn's workforce density and ship-construction tempo made it one of the most heavily exposed yards in the network. Notable mesothelioma compensation includes a combined approximately $190 million awarded to five Brooklyn Navy Yard workers diagnosed with mesothelioma after years of asbestos exposure at the yard — among the largest combined yard-worker recoveries on record.
Which U.S. Navy shipyards had the worst asbestos exposure?
Pearl Harbor's risk is quantified in a published cohort: among 7,029 Hawaii residents in it, mesothelioma incidence in 1977–1982 was 67.3 per million men per year, against 5.8 for the state as a whole.[7] Brooklyn employed some 70,000 people at its World War II peak.[1]
Asbestos Eras: From World War II Through Decommissioning
World War II (1940–1945): The Construction Surge
Nationwide, shipyard employment peaked at 1,723,000 in December 1943; employment in U.S. navy yards peaked earlier, at 333,000 in July 1943.[2] U.S. asbestos use averaged 783 million pounds a year during the World War II years, compared to 197 million pounds in the Depression year of 1932.[19]
Korean War and FRAM Program (1950s–1960s): The Modernization Wave
The FRAM program (described in detail in the next section) extended the service life of WWII-era destroyers and required yard workers to strip and replace existing asbestos insulation systems. Where WWII workers were exposed primarily through new-construction insulation installation, the 1950s–1960s cohort was exposed through the disturbance of legacy materials — a process that often produced higher airborne fiber concentrations than original installation, because torn-out insulation aerosolized fibers as it came out.
Vietnam Era and Cold War Submarine Construction (1960s–1970s)
Through the late 1960s and 1970s, yard work shifted toward nuclear-submarine construction, overhaul, and refueling. Submarines posed the most extreme confined-space asbestos exposure of any vessel type because crew and yard workers operated in sealed compartments with recirculated ventilation. All U.S. submarines built between 1922 and the early 1980s contained asbestos in flanges, gaskets, insulation, packing, piping, seals, tape, valves, water pipes, deck coverings, bulkhead panels, and engine-room lagging.
Decommissioning and Asbestos Abatement (1980s–Present)
Federal specifications eliminated asbestos lagging and insulation requirements for subsidized ship construction beginning in 1978, and the Navy phased asbestos out of new-build vessels through the 1980s. Yard work in the 1980s and 1990s shifted toward asbestos abatement under the OSHA 1915.1001 shipyard asbestos standard, which mandates engineering controls, regulated work areas, respiratory protection, exposure monitoring, and medical surveillance.[5] Modern abatement is significantly safer than legacy work, but every pre-1980 vessel still entering yard work — and many in active service or reserve fleet status — must be presumed to contain asbestos.
The Fleet Rehabilitation and Modernization (FRAM) Program
The Fleet Rehabilitation and Modernization (FRAM) program ran from 1959 through the late 1960s and was central to the asbestos exposure record at every yard with destroyer overhaul capacity. The program extended the service life of WWII-era Allen M. Sumner- and Gearing-class destroyers by approximately 8 to 12 years through systematic upgrades: new long-range radar, ASROC anti-submarine rocket launchers, DASH (drone anti-submarine helicopter) facilities, modernized sonar, hull strengthening, and updated propulsion auxiliaries.
The asbestos consequence was that nearly every FRAM rework required removing and replacing legacy steam-system insulation, boiler lagging, gaskets, and packing — effectively re-exposing the entire engineering plant. Yard workers performed this work in compartments still in use for adjacent system testing, which meant insulators, pipefitters, machinists, electricians, and laborers shared overlapping confined spaces. Industrial-hygiene measurements from FRAM-era work do not exist in the public record at the granularity later studies provide, but the trade-specific mortality patterns observed in international yard cohorts (described in detail at Shipyard_Workers) match the FRAM exposure profile precisely.
The destroyers modernized under FRAM remained in active service through the 1970s, which means yard workers at every Atlantic and Pacific yard with FRAM workload — Boston, Philadelphia, Norfolk, Long Beach, Mare Island, and Pearl Harbor — accumulated additional asbestos exposure each time a FRAM ship returned for routine availability or battle-damage repair.
High-Risk Trades — Cross-Reference
In the 55-year Genoa shipyard follow-up of 3,984 workers, pleural cancer standardized mortality ratios (SMRs) were statistically significant (p < 0.05) in 13 of 18 trades, from 1,703 for insulation workers down to 514 for ship demolishers.[20] A prospective cohort of 3,893 shipyard workers, mainly exposed to chrysotile, recorded 11 pleural mesotheliomas against 1.5 expected, about 7.3 times higher, while showing no increased lung cancer risk 7 to 15 years after exposure had ceased.[21]
The full SMR dataset, trade-by-trade exposure profiles, and bystander-exposure documentation live at Shipyard_Workers. That page also covers take-home (para-occupational) exposure to spouses and children of yard workers, which has produced its own substantial body of mesothelioma cases and litigation.
Compensation Pathways for Navy Shipyard Workers
Civilian Workers (LHWCA + Trust Funds + Civil Suits)
Civilian U.S. Navy shipyard workers — pipefitters, insulators, boilermakers, electricians, machinists, sheet metal workers, riggers, and laborers — are typically covered by the federal Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act (33 U.S.C. § 901 et seq.). LHWCA provides medical coverage for reasonable treatment, disability payments at two-thirds of average weekly wages, and death benefits for surviving dependents.[9] Coverage applies to workers performing maritime employment on navigable waters or in adjoining areas, including shipyards, piers, terminals, and dry docks.
LHWCA does not preclude civil lawsuits against the asbestos product manufacturers that supplied the Navy, and most yard workers were exposed to products from many different manufacturers across a career, so asbestos trust fund claims and product-liability suits are ordinarily pursued alongside an LHWCA claim.
That parallel track carries a statutory condition that must be handled before any settlement is signed. LHWCA compensation is offset against a third-party recovery under 33 U.S.C. § 933(f), and § 933(g) provides that where a covered worker settles a third-party claim for less than their LHWCA entitlement without prior written approval from the employer and the employer's carrier, and approval by the person entitled to compensation — or fails to notify the employer of any third-party settlement or judgment at all — "all rights to compensation and medical benefits under this chapter shall be terminated."[15] A worker can lose federal medical coverage for mesothelioma by settling in the wrong order. See Longshore_and_Harbor_Workers_Compensation_Act and the parallel-pathways discussion below.
The U.S. Government Accountability Office reported that the number of asbestos personal-injury trusts grew from 16 trusts with a combined total of $4.2 billion in assets in 2000 to 60 trusts with a combined total of over $36.8 billion in assets in 2011 — a figure the same report describes as the "total initial assets for the 60 trusts."[3] That is a 2011 measure of assets at funding, not a statement of what remains available in 2026, and each trust pays only a fraction of its scheduled value, revised periodically. Major trust funds relevant to Navy yard exposure include the Manville Trust (Johns-Manville), the Owens Corning/Fibreboard Trust, the PCC Trust (Pittsburgh Corning), and the Eagle-Picher Trust. Most yard workers qualify to file with 10 to 20 trusts simultaneously based on their documented product exposure history. (The full process and timeline is documented at Asbestos_Trust_Funds.)
Active-Duty and Veteran Personnel (VA Disability + DIC + Trust Funds)
Active-duty Navy personnel and veterans whose asbestos exposure occurred during military service — including service aboard ships built or overhauled at the yards in this hub — pursue VA disability compensation through an M21-1 nexus claim. Mesothelioma is not a PACT Act presumptive condition, so a veteran must document in-service asbestos exposure (via military occupational specialty, ship or duty-station records, or buddy statements) and obtain a physician's medical nexus opinion linking the diagnosis to that exposure, typically confirmed at a VA Compensation & Pension exam.[10][22][12][13][4][14] Once service connection is established, mesothelioma is typically rated at 100% disability for VA purposes.
VA pathways include monthly disability compensation, Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC) for surviving spouses, Aid and Attendance for veterans needing daily assistance, and access to specialized mesothelioma treatment programs through VA medical centers and affiliated hospitals.[23] See VA_Benefits_for_Veterans_with_Mesothelioma for the full benefits framework.
2026 VA Disability Compensation Rates
The 2026 VA disability compensation rates (effective December 1, 2025 through November 30, 2026 following the annual COLA adjustment) are:[11]
| VA Disability Rating | 2026 Monthly Rate (Veteran Alone) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 100% | $3,938.58 | Rating follows once service connection is established via M21-1 nexus claim |
| 90% | $2,297.96 | Significant chronic asbestos disease |
| 80% | $2,044.89 | Substantial pulmonary impairment |
| 70% | $1,759.19 | Moderate-severe pulmonary impairment |
| DIC (surviving spouse) | $1,699.36 | Plus dependent supplements |
Veterans with a spouse, dependent children, or dependent parents receive higher monthly rates than the veteran-alone figures shown. DIC is paid when a veteran's death is service-connected — which mesothelioma typically is for any veteran with documented Navy asbestos exposure.
Pursuing All Pathways in Parallel
VA disability, asbestos trust fund claims, and product-liability lawsuits run on separate legal tracks and are generally pursued together. VA disability compensation is not reduced by a tort or trust recovery. Whether a trust payment reduces a civil verdict is a question of state setoff law and varies by jurisdiction, so the combined net effect should be evaluated under the law of the state where suit is filed.
LHWCA is the exception, and the difference is consequential. Federal Longshore benefits do not run free of a third-party recovery. Under 33 U.S.C. § 933(f), where the worker recovers from a third party the employer is required to pay "a sum equal to the excess of the amount which the Secretary determines is payable on account of such injury or death over the net amount recovered against such third person" — an offset by operation of statute, not a discretionary one.[15]
Section 933(g) carries a harsher consequence. Where a covered worker settles with a third party for less than the compensation they would be entitled to under the Act, § 933(g)(1) makes the employer liable only if written approval of that settlement is obtained from the employer and the employer's carrier before the settlement is executed, and by the person entitled to compensation (or that person's representative), on a form provided by the Secretary and filed with the deputy commissioner within thirty days. Section 933(g)(2) then provides that if no such approval is obtained and filed, "or if the employee fails to notify the employer of any settlement obtained from or judgment rendered against a third person, all rights to compensation and medical benefits under this chapter shall be terminated, regardless of whether the employer or the employer's insurer has made payments or acknowledged entitlement to benefits under this chapter."[15] The notice obligation in that second clause is not limited to below-entitlement settlements — it reaches any third-party settlement or judgment.
For an LHWCA-covered shipyard worker, the sequence and paperwork of a third-party settlement are therefore not administrative detail. They are the difference between keeping and forfeiting federal medical coverage for a terminal illness. Any Navy-yard worker who is receiving or may be eligible for LHWCA benefits should have the § 933 approval and notice requirements handled by counsel before any settlement is executed. The statutory framework is set out in full at Longshore_and_Harbor_Workers_Compensation_Act.
Subject to that constraint, the general maximum-recovery approach for a Navy-yard worker or veteran with mesothelioma is to file with every applicable trust, pursue civil claims against still-operating manufacturer defendants, and (for veterans) maintain VA disability and DIC claims — sequenced so that § 933 approval and notice are secured first wherever LHWCA coverage is in play.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which U.S. Navy shipyards are still active in 2026?
Four of the nine principal Navy shipyards remain active: Puget Sound Naval Shipyard (Bremerton, WA), Norfolk Naval Shipyard (Portsmouth, VA), Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard (Pearl Harbor, HI), and Portsmouth Naval Shipyard (Kittery, ME). Five — Boston/Charlestown, Mare Island, Philadelphia, Long Beach, and Brooklyn — are closed or repurposed.
Did all Navy yards use the same asbestos products?
Substantially yes. Navy MIL-SPECs governed asbestos use across the entire fleet, so the same categories of asbestos-containing products — chrysotile and amosite pipe insulation, boiler lagging, sprayed fireproofing, gaskets, packing, deck tile, electrical insulation — were used at every yard from the 1930s through the early 1980s. Specific manufacturers (Johns-Manville, Owens Corning, Pittsburgh Corning, Eagle-Picher, Garlock) supplied multiple yards, which is why most Navy-yard plaintiffs qualify to file with the same major trust funds regardless of which yard they worked at.
If I worked at one of these yards in the 1960s, am I still at risk for mesothelioma in 2026?
Yes. The mesothelioma latency period is 20 to 60 years from first asbestos exposure. A worker exposed in the 1960s is well within the diagnosis window in 2026, and yard workers from that era continue to receive new diagnoses every year. Anyone with documented yard exposure who develops persistent chest pain, shortness of breath, or pleural effusion should be evaluated for mesothelioma, ideally at a mesothelioma specialist center.
Can civilians who worked at a Navy yard file VA claims?
Civilian workers do not qualify for VA disability benefits — VA benefits are limited to veterans of the uniformed services. Civilian shipyard workers pursue compensation through LHWCA federal workers' compensation, asbestos trust funds, and product-liability lawsuits. These pathways do not simply add together the way a veteran's do: under 33 U.S.C. 933(f) the LHWCA employer's obligation is reduced by a third-party recovery, whereas VA disability compensation is not reduced by a trust or tort recovery. A civilian's net combined figure therefore depends on how the LHWCA offset and state setoff law apply to the specific recoveries involved.
What is the FRAM program and why does it matter for asbestos cases?
The Fleet Rehabilitation and Modernization (FRAM) program (1959–late 1960s) extended the service life of WWII-era destroyers by upgrading their weapons, sensors, and engineering systems. FRAM rework required stripping and replacing legacy asbestos insulation, which exposed yard workers to a second wave of high-concentration asbestos disturbance after the WWII construction surge. FRAM-era yard workers (1959–1969) are a distinct exposure cohort whose latency window extends from the 1980s well into the 2030s.
Are wives and children of yard workers also at risk?
Yes. Take-home (para-occupational, secondary) exposure occurs when yard workers carried asbestos fibers home on their clothing, hair, and skin, exposing family members who laundered work clothes or shared confined home spaces. Multiple court decisions — including Quisenberry v. Huntington Ingalls Industries in Virginia — have recognized employer liability for take-home exposure. See Secondary_Asbestos_Exposure for the full pathway, epidemiology, and litigation framework.
Where can I file a claim if I worked at one of these yards?
Claim filing depends on whether the worker was civilian or uniformed. Civilians: contact a maritime/asbestos attorney to evaluate LHWCA, trust fund, and lawsuit pathways. Veterans: file the VA disability claim plus parallel trust fund claims. Both groups: gather employment or service records (DD-214 for veterans, employment records or Social Security earnings statements for civilians) and any documentation that places the worker in specific compartments aboard specific ships during the heavy-asbestos era. The full pathway is documented at Filing_a_Mesothelioma_Claim.
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 History of the Yard, Brooklyn Navy Yard Development Corporation
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Wartime Employment, Production, and Conditions of Work in Shipyards, Bulletin No. 824, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1945 (via FRASER, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis)
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Asbestos Injury Compensation: The Role and Administration of Asbestos Trusts, GAO-11-819, U.S. Government Accountability Office, September 2011. Reports that asbestos personal injury trusts grew from "16 trusts with a combined total of $4.2 billion in assets in 2000 to 60 with a combined total of over $36.8 billion in assets in 2011," and separately characterizes that sum as the "total initial assets for the 60 trusts" — a figure at funding, not assets remaining.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. 29 CFR 1915.1001 — Asbestos (shipyard employment standard). osha.gov/laws-regs/regulations/standardnumber/1915/1915.1001
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 U.S. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Toxicological Profile for Asbestos. cdc.gov/niosh/topics/asbestos/
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 Kolonel LN, Yoshizawa CN, Hirohata T, Myers BC. Cancer occurrence in shipyard workers exposed to asbestos in Hawaii. Cancer Res. 1985. PMID 4016758. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4016758/
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 Krstev S, Stewart P, Rusiecki J, Blair A. Mortality among shipyard Coast Guard workers: a retrospective cohort study. Occup Environ Med. 2007 Oct. PMID 17881470. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17881470/
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 U.S. Department of Labor, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs. Division of Federal Employees', Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation. dol.gov/agencies/owcp/dlhwc
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. The PACT Act and your VA benefits. va.gov/resources/the-pact-act-and-your-va-benefits/
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. 2026 VA disability compensation rates (effective December 1, 2025). va.gov/disability/compensation-rates/veteran-rates/
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 38 CFR 3.309 — Disease subject to presumptive service connection, Code of Federal Regulations. Subsection (e), herbicide-agent presumptives, lists "Soft-tissue sarcoma (other than osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, Kaposi's sarcoma, or mesothelioma)" — mesothelioma is named only to exclude it.
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 13.2 38 CFR 3.316 — Claims based on chronic effects of exposure to mustard gas and Lewisite, Code of Federal Regulations. Lists the presumptive cancers as "Nasopharyngeal; laryngeal; lung (except mesothelioma); or squamous cell carcinoma of the skin" — again an explicit exclusion.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 38 CFR 3.320 — Claims based on exposure to fine particulate matter, Code of Federal Regulations. The PACT-era burn-pit and airborne-hazard presumptive regulation; neither mesothelioma nor asbestos appears anywhere in it.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 33 U.S.C. § 933 — Compensation for injuries where third persons are liable, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. Subsection (f) offsets employer liability by the net amount recovered from a third person; subsection (g)(1) requires written approval of a below-entitlement settlement from the employer and the employer's carrier before execution, and by the person entitled to compensation (or that person's representative), filed within thirty days; subsection (g)(2) terminates all rights to compensation and medical benefits where that approval is not obtained and filed, or where the employee fails to notify the employer of any third-party settlement or judgment.
- ↑ NPL Site Narrative for Norfolk Naval Shipyard, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (conditions at proposal, March 6, 1998)
- ↑ Charlestown Navy Yard, Boston National Historical Park, U.S. National Park Service
- ↑ U.S. Environmental Protection Agency / Department of Defense. Charlestown Navy Yard Formerly Used Defense Site. epa.gov/superfund
- ↑ Hedley-Whyte J, Milamed DR. Asbestos and Ship-Building: Fatal Consequences. Ulster Med J 2008;77(3):191-200.
- ↑ Merlo DF, Bruzzone M, Bruzzi P, et al. Mortality among workers exposed to asbestos at the shipyard of Genoa, Italy: a 55 years follow-up. Environ Health. 2018;17(1):94. PMID 30594195. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30594195/
- ↑ Sandén A, Järvholm B, Larsson S, Thiringer G. The risk of lung cancer and mesothelioma after cessation of asbestos exposure: a prospective cohort study of shipyard workers. Eur Respir J. 1992. PMID 1572439. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1572439/
- ↑ PACT Act (Public Law 117-168), U.S. Congress
- ↑ U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Asbestos exposure and your health. va.gov/disability/eligibility/hazardous-materials-exposure/asbestos/
External Links
- AsbestosAtlas.org — U.S. Shipyard Asbestos Exposure Dataset — AsbestosAtlas.org records 99 verified findings across 37 major U.S. naval and commercial shipyards for the period 1898 to the present, together with 87 catalogued asbestos products, employment time series, and EPA Superfund status; each finding is attributed to a primary record in PubMed, NIOSH, EPA, or NARA. Created and funded by Danziger & De Llano, LLP, licensed CC BY 4.0, and archived at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21627565. It is a secondary compilation drawn from the same primary literature this page cites directly, and is offered as a facility-level finding aid rather than as independent corroboration of the studies above.
See also
- Shipyard_Workers — Trade-by-trade SMR data, bystander exposure, and international cohort comparison
- Brooklyn_Navy_Yard — New York Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Boston_Naval_Shipyard — Charlestown Navy Yard yard-specific page
- Long_Beach_Naval_Shipyard — Long Beach Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Mare_Island_Naval_Shipyard — Mare Island yard-specific page
- Norfolk_Naval_Shipyard — Norfolk Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Pearl_Harbor_Naval_Shipyard — Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Philadelphia_Naval_Shipyard — Philadelphia Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Portsmouth_Naval_Shipyard — Portsmouth Naval Shipyard (Kittery, ME) yard-specific page
- Puget_Sound_Naval_Shipyard — Puget Sound Naval Shipyard yard-specific page
- Navy_Asbestos_Exposure — Fleet-wide Navy asbestos exposure overview
- Korean_War_Asbestos_Exposure — Korean War-era exposure context
- Vietnam_War_Asbestos_Exposure — Vietnam War-era exposure context
- Asbestos_Trust_Funds — Trust fund framework and filing process
- VA_Benefits_for_Veterans_with_Mesothelioma — VA disability, DIC, and PACT Act benefits framework
- Secondary_Asbestos_Exposure — Take-home (para-occupational) exposure to family members
- Mesothelioma_Specialists — Mesothelioma specialist treatment centers