Asbestos Podcast EP47 Transcript
Episode 47: The Ban That Finally Came
Full transcript from Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making — a 52-episode documentary podcast produced by Danziger & De Llano, LLP.
| Episode Information | |
|---|---|
| Series | Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making |
| Season | 1 |
| Episode | 47 |
| Title | The Ban That Finally Came |
| Arc | Arc 9 — The Ongoing Cover-Up (episode 5, the arc finale) |
| Era Covered | The federal chrysotile asbestos rule of 2024, from the 1989 ban the Fifth Circuit vacated through litigation current to October 2026 |
| Produced by | Charles Fletcher |
| Research and writing | Charles Fletcher with Claude AI |
| Listen | Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube |
| Episode page | Episode 47 on Mesothelioma Lawyers Near Me |
Episode Summary
Episode 47 closes Arc 9 with the federal rule on chrysotile asbestos and reads its fine print through three words: "chrysotile," "banned" and "final." EPA announced the rule on March 18, 2024,[1] and published it on March 28, 2024 as 89 Fed. Reg. 21970, effective May 28, 2024.[2] EPA describes chrysotile as "the only known form of asbestos currently used in or imported to the United States," and the rule was the first finalized under the 2016 amendments to the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA).[1]
The first word is "chrysotile." TSCA defines asbestos as the asbestiform varieties of six fiber types, of which chrysotile is one, and the rule addresses chrysotile because, in EPA's words, it is "the only form of asbestos manufactured (including imported), processed, or distributed for use in the United States today".[2] EPA is evaluating the other fiber types, and legacy uses of asbestos already in place, separately in part 2 of its asbestos risk evaluation.[1] The second word is "banned": the rule regulates what EPA calls "non-legacy conditions of use" of chrysotile, and EPA is evaluating legacy uses and associated disposal separately, in part 2;[2] asbestos already installed in buildings is the subject of the next episode.
The third word is "final." The rule prohibited the manufacture, including import, of chrysotile for chlor-alkali diaphragms as of its effective date, and phased out its processing and use in those diaphragms over five years, with up to eight and twelve years for a company converting several plants to membrane technology.[2] Most asbestos sheet gaskets were banned two years after the effective date, gaskets used to produce titanium dioxide and to process nuclear material got five years, and gaskets at the Department of Energy's Savannah River Site may be used through calendar year 2037.[1] Oilfield brake blocks, aftermarket automotive brakes and linings, other vehicle friction products and other gaskets were banned six months after the effective date.[1] The episode credits one company, Olin, with an early conversion; the record shows the opposite, as the Notes on the Audio explain.[3]
The history explains why the 2024 rule was possible at all. EPA began its asbestos rulemaking under TSCA in 1979 and in 1989 issued a rule to prohibit asbestos "in almost all products"; on October 18, 1991, in Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, the Fifth Circuit vacated that rule and remanded it, holding EPA to TSCA's requirement that it use "the least burdensome requirements".[4] The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act, signed June 22, 2016, amended TSCA,[5] and EPA's 2024 rule records that the amendments reflect Congress's intent to "delete the paralyzing 'least burdensome' requirement".[2]
The litigation passage is current to October 16, 2026. Challenges to the rule were consolidated in the Fifth Circuit as Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193. The industry petitioners presented three issues: that EPA's risk evaluation rested on worst-case assumptions; that EPA exceeded its authority by not referring its findings to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration under TSCA section 9; and that the rule goes beyond "the extent necessary" without a real alternative to a ban.[6] In February 2025 the court put the case on hold for 120 days so new agency leadership could review the rule; on June 16, 2025 EPA asked for six more months to reconsider the rule through new rulemaking, and on July 7, 2025 it withdrew that motion because it "no longer intends to conduct notice-and-comment rulemaking to evaluate potential changes at this time".[7] In May 2026 Olin dismissed its petition with prejudice,[8] and the industry petitioners withdrew their worst-case-assumptions issue and said they would not seek vacatur of EPA's risk evaluation.[6] Before the June 1, 2026 argument the panel asked counsel to be ready to discuss whether the petitioners had established standing,[9] and afterward it asked for letter briefs on whether standing had been shown and, if not, "whether each petition for review must be dismissed".[10] No decision had been posted as of October 16, 2026.[11]
While the asbestos case waited, the same court decided another rule under the same statute. On September 15, 2026, in East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA, a Fifth Circuit panel granted the industry petition and vacated EPA's 2024 methylene chloride rule and its associated risk determination, the 2022 determination that had replaced condition-of-use findings with a "whole chemical" basis and dropped the assumption that workers wear personal protective equipment.[12] The court held that the no-protective-equipment assumption "was contrary to law, arbitrary and capricious, and lacked substantial evidence," that the risk analysis "did not accord with the best available science," and that "'Unreasonable risk' does not incorporate any precautionary principle".[12] East Fork concerns a different chemical and did not decide the asbestos case. The episode's argument that its holdings map onto the asbestos challengers' case is the hosts' analysis, and the standing questions the court asked in the asbestos case could end it without a ruling on the merits.[10]
Key Takeaways
|
Key Concepts
Three Words Doing Enormous Work: The episode's frame. "Chrysotile" is one fiber type of the six in TSCA's definition;[2] "banned" covers asbestos in commerce, while legacy uses are evaluated separately;[1] and "final" is a schedule, not a date, running through calendar year 2037 at the Savannah River Site.[1]
Died on Grammar: The hosts' phrase for the 1989 ban: the Fifth Circuit vacated it under TSCA's requirement that EPA use "the least burdensome requirements,"[4] and the 2016 amendments set out to "delete the paralyzing 'least burdensome' requirement".[2]
Same Villain, Same Courtroom: The rule went to the Fifth Circuit, the court that decided Corrosion Proof Fittings in 1991[4] and that heard Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA on June 1, 2026.[11] "Villain" is the hosts' word for a court.
"That's Not Enforcement. That's a Mood.": The hosts' line for EPA's 2025 reversal: on June 16, 2025 it asked to keep the case on hold for six more months while it reconsidered the rule, then withdrew the request on July 7, 2025.[7]
The Rule Next Door: East Fork vacated EPA's methylene chloride rule and its risk determination under the same statute.[12] The industry petitioners' remaining asbestos issues include the claim that the rule goes beyond "the extent necessary";[6] the episode calls East Fork a blueprint, which is argument, not a ruling on asbestos.
A Receipt Good Through 2037: The farthest date in the rule is the Savannah River Site gasket allowance, through calendar year 2037.[1] EPA tied it to the site's commitment to complete its liquid waste program by the end of 2037.[2]
Named as Progress: The episode insists on both claims at once: the rule is the first finalized under the 2016 amendments and closed the last import stream of raw chrysotile,[1][2] and it leaves other fiber types and installed asbestos to later work. "About a quarter of the problem" is the hosts' accounting, not a measured fraction.
Fine Print as the Native Habitat: The close: "A ban with fine print is still a ban." / "The fine print is where this story has lived for a hundred years. We keep reading it out loud."
Frequently Asked Questions
| Did the United States ban asbestos in 2024? |
|---|
| It banned the ongoing uses of one kind. EPA announced the rule on March 18, 2024, prohibiting ongoing uses of chrysotile asbestos, "the only known form of asbestos currently used in or imported to the United States".[1] The rule was published March 28, 2024 (89 Fed. Reg. 21970) and took effect May 28, 2024.[2] It phases out the last uses over six months to twelve years, with sheet gaskets at the Department of Energy's Savannah River Site allowed through calendar year 2037, and EPA is evaluating other fiber types and legacy asbestos separately.[1] |
| Why did the 1989 asbestos ban fail, and what changed in 2016? |
|---|
| EPA began the rulemaking in 1979 and issued a rule in 1989 to prohibit asbestos in almost all products. On October 18, 1991, the Fifth Circuit vacated it in Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, applying TSCA's requirement that EPA use "the least burdensome requirements"; the court left EPA able to ban products that were not being manufactured, imported or processed on July 12, 1989, the date the rule was issued.[4] The Lautenberg Act, signed June 22, 2016, amended TSCA,[5] and EPA's 2024 rule cites Congress's intent to "delete the paralyzing 'least burdensome' requirement".[2] |
| Is the 2024 asbestos ban still in effect? |
|---|
| Yes, as of October 16, 2026, and it is under challenge. Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA (No. 24-60193) was argued in the Fifth Circuit on June 1, 2026, and no decision had been posted as of October 16, 2026.[11] The panel asked the parties to address whether the petitioners have standing and whether each petition must be dismissed if they do not.[10] In 2025 EPA asked for six more months to reconsider the rule, then withdrew that request.[7] |
| What was the East Fork decision, and what does it mean for the asbestos ban? |
|---|
| On September 15, 2026, a Fifth Circuit panel in East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA vacated EPA's 2024 methylene chloride rule and its associated risk determination, which had replaced condition-of-use findings with a "whole chemical" basis and assumed workers wear no protective equipment.[12] The court held that assumption "contrary to law," found the risk analysis "did not accord with the best available science," and wrote that "'Unreasonable risk' does not incorporate any precautionary principle".[12] The decision concerns a different chemical and does not decide the asbestos case, in which the court has asked whether each petition must be dismissed for lack of standing.[10] |
| Does the ban remove asbestos already in buildings? |
|---|
| No. The 2024 rule prohibits the import, processing, distribution and use of chrysotile for the uses it lists; EPA is addressing legacy uses of asbestos separately, in part 2 of its risk evaluation.[1] Asbestos already installed in older buildings is the subject of Episode 48, "The Hidden Asbestos." |
| Does the ban help people already sick from asbestos? |
|---|
| No. The rule governs future commerce in chrysotile;[1] asbestos diseases appear decades after exposure (see Mesothelioma_Latency_Period), and compensation for past exposure runs through lawsuits, asbestos trust funds and, for veterans, VA benefits. Trust claims and lawsuits can be pursued in parallel, and Danziger & De Llano, the firm featured in this episode, pursues both trust fund claims and lawsuits.[13] AsbestosTrusts.org lists documented U.S. asbestos bankruptcy trusts with payment percentages, net assets and source confidence ratings.[14] Consultations are free at dandell.com. |
Full Transcript
Verbatim as aired. Where the audio is imprecise or goes beyond the documented record, see Notes on the Audio below.
Host 1: March 28, 2024. The Environmental Protection Agency issues a final rule banning chrysotile asbestos in the United States. It is the first time in American history that a comprehensive federal asbestos ban has actually taken effect. After a century of mines and shipyards and cover-ups, after Borel, after Libby, after the baby powder — the government finally, actually banned it.
Host 2: I've been on this show long enough to hear the shoe still in the air. That was a very clean sentence. What's wrong with it?
Host 1: Three words in it are doing enormous work. "Chrysotile." "Final." And "banned." We're going to spend the episode on all three, because this is a real victory that is also nowhere near what it sounds like.
Host 2: Today on Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making—
Host 1: Episode 47: The Ban That Finally Came.
Host 2: They banned it. Read the fine print before you celebrate.
Host 2: Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making is brought to you by Danziger and De Llano, still filing claims for exposure that happened long before any ban, and will for decades to come. dandell.com. That's D-A-N-D-E-L-L dot com.
Host 1: To understand 2024, you have to hold Episode Thirty-Nine in your head. 1989: the EPA bans almost all asbestos after ten years of work. 1991: the Fifth Circuit throws it out, saying the agency didn't prove it picked the least burdensome option. That ruling froze federal asbestos regulation for more than thirty years. So the first question about the 2024 ban is: what changed that made it possible at all?
Host 2: Because the law that sank the 1989 ban was still on the books.
Host 1: Until 2016. That year Congress amended the Toxic Substances Control Act — the Lautenberg Act — and stripped out the exact "least burdensome" language the Fifth Circuit had used to kill the old ban. They pulled the murder weapon out of the statute. That's what unlocked 2024. The 1989 ban didn't fail because the science was weak. It failed because of a phrase in a law. It took twenty-five years to delete the phrase.
Host 2: So now word one. "Chrysotile." The 2024 ban covers chrysotile asbestos. What about the others?
Host 1: Not covered. There are six recognized asbestos fiber types. The rule bans one of them — chrysotile — because it's the only kind still being imported and used in the US. The other five, including the amphiboles we've spent the whole series calling the deadliest forms, aren't addressed by this rule.
Host 2: They banned the one that was still being sold and left the more dangerous ones unmentioned. Because nobody's importing those anymore. So the ban covers the fiber that's here, and skips the fibers that already did their killing and are sitting in the walls.
Host 1: Which is word three, and the biggest gap. "Banned" covers new asbestos entering commerce. It does not touch legacy asbestos — the material already installed in millions of buildings. The rule bans bringing more in. It does nothing about the tonnage already in the pipes, the tiles, the insulation, the schools. That's next episode, and it's the one that's actually in your house.
Host 2: And word two. "Final." You leaned on that one.
Host 1: Because there was still one industry importing chrysotile right up to 2024 — the chlor-alkali industry, which uses asbestos diaphragms to make chlorine and bleach. The rule banned new imports immediately. But existing plants? They got a phase-out. Some as short as a couple of years. Some chemical facilities got five to twelve years to convert. And certain asbestos gaskets at a federal nuclear site got a timeline running to 2037.
Host 2: 2037. A child born the day the ban was signed will be in high school before some of this asbestos use ends. That's the "final" ban.
Host 1: One company, Olin, volunteered to convert within about two years and showed it could be done. Others took the long timelines. So "final" means "phased out over up to twelve years, with a carve-out to 2037." It's a real ban. It's also a negotiation.
Host 2: And none of this — not one word of the 2024 rule — helps the person diagnosed next month from exposure in 1985. That's why the claims system matters, and why it moves slowly unless someone builds the case right. Danziger and De Llano files complete, and files every trust at once — the difference between ninety days and a year is usually the paperwork. dandell.com.
Host 2: So the ban passes in March 2024. Is that the end? Please tell me the story lets us have one clean ending.
Host 1: It does not. Because the ban went exactly where the last one went. Industry groups sued — and the case, Texas Chemistry Council versus EPA, landed in the Fifth Circuit. The same court. The same court that killed the ban in 1991 now holds the fate of the ban in 2024.
Host 2: You're telling me the sequel has the same villain and the same courtroom.
Host 1: The industry argument is that the EPA overstepped — that workplace exposure should be OSHA's job, not a TSCA ban. Public health groups filed briefs saying what this whole series has said: there is no safe level of exposure. And then it got stranger. In mid-2025, the EPA itself — under a new administration — asked the court to pause the case so it could reconsider its own rule. The court paused it. And then, a few weeks later, the EPA withdrew that request and decided not to revise the rule after all.
Host 2: The agency sued to defend its own ban, then asked to reconsider it, then changed its mind about reconsidering. That's not enforcement. That's a mood.
Host 1: The agency has said that if it ever did rewrite the rule, the process could take up to thirty more months. And while everyone waited, the court answered a different case. September 15, 2026 — a month before we recorded this. East Fork Enterprises versus EPA. The methylene chloride ban — another rule, written under the same amended statute. A unanimous panel vacated the rule, and the risk finding underneath it.
Host 2: On what grounds?
Host 1: Read the list and tell me it doesn't sound familiar. The agency must judge risk use by use, not for the chemical as a whole. It may not assume workers go unprotected — protective equipment counts. Its science has to answer the contrary studies in the record, not ignore them. And it may regulate only to the extent necessary — it has to weigh the less drastic options. That is not four technicalities. That is the industry's entire brief in the asbestos case — already law of the circuit.
Host 2: So the court that killed the ban in 1991 just showed everyone exactly how it would kill this one.
Host 1: Almost. One thread runs the other way. When the asbestos case was argued, this June, the judges spent most of the hour on a different question — whether the challengers even have the right to be in court. Standing. The biggest users have already walked away from chrysotile; the injury is getting hard to find. The court could throw the case out without ever touching the rule. So as of today: the ban is in effect. The challenge is pending. The court has shown its hand on the statute — and kept its hand hidden on standing.
Host 2: So let me total this up. The ban covers one of six fibers. It exempts everything already installed. It phases out the last real use over as long as twelve years, with a piece running to 2037. And it's parked at the mercy of the same court that killed the last one — and that just vacated the rule next door.
Host 1: Yes. And I still want to be fair to it, because the people who fought for decades to get here deserve that. It is the first federal asbestos ban to survive to enforcement. It closed the single largest remaining import stream. It is real progress, and real progress in this story is rare enough that we should name it as progress.
Host 2: I'll give it that. It's the best ban America has ever managed. It's just that "the best ban America has ever managed" arrives in 2024, covers a quarter of the problem, and comes with a receipt good through 2037.
Host 1: Four thousand five hundred years from a Finnish cooking pot to a partial ban with a homework problem attached. That's not a finish line. It's the first time the country even drew one.
Host 2: The man who'd tell you not to wait for Washington is Rod De Llano. Rod's a founding partner at Danziger and De Llano — but he started on the other side, at a big firm, defending corporations in product-liability cases. He was good at it. Good enough to know exactly how a company runs out the clock, and exactly what that clock costs the person on the other side of it. So he left, and for thirty years he's used what he learned to beat it. If your family is facing a diagnosis, you don't wait for a rule to work. You call. Danziger and De Llano. dandell.com — D-A-N-D-E-L-L dot com.
Host 1: Paul Danziger and Rod De Llano founded the firm in 1995. Nearly two billion dollars recovered. Over a thousand families. Cases in all fifty states.
Host 2: The consultation is free, seven days a week. dandell.com.
Host 1: You've been listening to Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making. Episode 47: The Ban That Finally Came.
Host 2: Research, writing, and production for this series is supported by Danziger and De Llano, a national mesothelioma law firm with over 30 years of experience and nearly two billion dollars recovered for victims and their families.
Host 1: That closes Arc Nine. Next time we begin the final arc — the fight that's still going on, in the present tense. And we start it where the 2024 ban stops: with the asbestos it doesn't touch. The material already inside the buildings. Your office. Your kid's school. The millions of older buildings that still contain it, sitting quietly in the ceiling tiles until somebody picks up a drill.
Host 2: The ban was about what comes in. This is about what's already here.
Host 1: Episode 48: The Hidden Asbestos. On Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making.
Host 2: A ban with fine print is still a ban.
Host 1: The fine print is where this story has lived for a hundred years. We keep reading it out loud.
Notes on the Audio
The transcript above is the episode as aired. Where a spoken line is imprecise or goes beyond the documented record, the record is:
- "One company, Olin, volunteered to convert within about two years and showed it could be done. Others took the long timelines." The record shows the reverse. In an April 4, 2023 letter Olin asked EPA to ban new or replacement asbestos diaphragms in two years while allowing existing diaphragm cells five more years, seven years in all; EPA found that Olin had not shown seven years was as soon as practicable and kept a five-year deadline for conversions like Olin's.[2] Olin, which describes itself as "the largest global and U.S. producer of chlor-alkali and the owner of the largest global and U.S. asbestos-based diaphragm chlor-alkali facility," filed a petition for review of the rule and then petitioned EPA for a time-limited exemption: "Olin requests an additional two years to convert its facilities from using asbestos diaphragm cells to using non-asbestos diaphragms," beyond the May 28, 2029 compliance deadline, with transition expected by May 2031.[3] Olin's court petition was dismissed with prejudice by stipulation filed May 6, 2026; the clerk's order dismissing it followed on May 15, 2026.[8][11]
- "The rule banned new imports immediately. But existing plants? They got a phase-out. Some as short as a couple of years. Some chemical facilities got five to twelve years to convert." The import prohibition for chlor-alkali took effect on the rule's effective date, May 28, 2024. No chlor-alkali facility received less than five years.[2] The two-year deadline applies to most asbestos sheet gaskets.[1]
- "A child born the day the ban was signed will be in high school before some of this asbestos use ends." The longest allowance, for sheet gaskets at the Savannah River Site, runs through calendar year 2037.[1] A child born on the March 18, 2024 announcement date would be 13 at the end of 2037, usually not yet in high school.
- "It is the first time in American history that a comprehensive federal asbestos ban has actually taken effect." Part of the 1989 rule survived Corrosion Proof Fittings: the court held EPA could "ban products that once were, but no longer are, being produced in the United States," which its clarification limited to products not being manufactured, imported or processed on July 12, 1989.[4] The 2024 rule is the first finalized under the 2016 amendments.[1]
- "That ruling froze federal asbestos regulation for more than thirty years." The Fifth Circuit's East Fork opinion notes that "Almost a decade later, EPA published a narrower asbestos rule aimed at protecting state and local government workers" (65 Fed. Reg. 69210, November 15, 2000).[12]
- "In mid-2025, the EPA itself — under a new administration — asked the court to pause the case so it could reconsider its own rule. The court paused it. And then, a few weeks later, the EPA withdrew that request." The case had already been paused: on February 14, 2025 the court granted EPA's motion to hold it in abeyance for 120 days so new agency leadership could review the rule. EPA's June 16, 2025 motion asked for six more months; on July 7, 2025 EPA withdrew it "in lieu of a reply" to an opposition, before the court ruled on it.[7] The court then extended the stay only through August 8, 2025.[11] The Ogletree Deakins post this page cites for the thirty-month estimate describes the six-month abeyance as granted; EPA's own filing shows the motion withdrawn instead.[15][7]
- "The agency sued to defend its own ban." EPA is the respondent in Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA; it was sued.[7] Olin's petition refers to EPA's "brief defending the Final Rule in litigation".[3]
- "The industry argument is that the EPA overstepped — that workplace exposure should be OSHA's job" and "That is the industry's entire brief in the asbestos case — already law of the circuit." The OSHA point is one of the industry petitioners' three issues (TSCA section 9). Before the argument, on May 19, 2026, they withdrew a second issue, that EPA's risk evaluation rested on worst-case assumptions rather than actual conditions of use, and said they do not seek vacatur of EPA's risk evaluation; they kept the section 9 issue and the claim that the rule goes beyond "the extent necessary".[6] The withdrawn issue is the one closest to the condition-of-use and protective-equipment holdings in East Fork.[12] Public-health organizations, physicians and scientists, firefighters' unions and the United Steelworkers are also petitioners, and the industry associations intervened to defend parts of the rule against their challenges.[6] The comparison to East Fork is the hosts' analysis.
- "The biggest users have already walked away from chrysotile; the injury is getting hard to find." Olin, which calls itself the largest U.S. chlor-alkali producer, says it plans to shut one of its three asbestos-diaphragm units in the first half of 2026 and is seeking more time to convert the other two.[3] The industry petitioners told the court in May 2026 that key compliance deadlines for their members' chlor-alkali plants had already passed, including the interim workplace exposure limit that took effect November 25, 2024.[6] The court's standing questions ask how standing must be shown and whether it has been shown here.[10]
- "Public health groups filed briefs saying what this whole series has said: there is no safe level of exposure." This page does not quote the briefs. EPA's rule calls chrysotile "a known human carcinogen,"[2] and the World Health Organization states: "No threshold has been identified for the carcinogenic risk of asbestos, including chrysotile."[16]
- "September 15, 2026 — a month before we recorded this." East Fork was filed September 15, 2026.[12] The litigation status on this page is as of October 16, 2026.[11]
- The firm's recovery figure and other statements about the firm. The firm's published figure is over $2 billion recovered for families nationwide.[17] The statistics and other statements about the firm and its personnel in the sponsor messages are the firm's own and are not independently sourced on this page.
Named Entities
| Name | Role / Significance |
|---|---|
| The 2024 chrysotile rule | EPA, "Asbestos Part 1; Chrysotile Asbestos; Regulation of Certain Conditions of Use Under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)," 89 Fed. Reg. 21970, published March 28, 2024 and effective May 28, 2024.[2] The first rule finalized under the 2016 TSCA amendments.[1] |
| Chrysotile | The serpentine fiber among the six fiber types in TSCA's definition of asbestos, and the only form manufactured (including imported), processed or distributed for use in the United States at the time of the rule; EPA calls it "a known human carcinogen".[2] |
| Chlor-alkali industry | The last importer of raw chrysotile, used in diaphragms that make chlorine and caustic soda. Import for that use was prohibited as of May 28, 2024, with processing and use phased out over five, eight or twelve years.[2][1] |
| Olin Corporation | A chlor-alkali producer that proposed a seven-year timeline EPA rejected,[2] petitioned for review of the rule, and petitioned EPA for two additional years past the May 28, 2029 compliance deadline.[3] Its court petition was dismissed with prejudice by stipulation filed May 6, 2026, and dismissed by clerk's order on May 15, 2026.[8][11] |
| Savannah River Site gaskets | Department of Energy nuclear site where asbestos-containing sheet gaskets may be used through calendar year 2037,[1] matching the site's commitment to complete its liquid waste program by the end of 2037.[2] |
| Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA | 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. October 18, 1991): vacated and remanded EPA's 1989 asbestos rule under TSCA's "least burdensome" requirement.[4] The subject of Episode 39. |
| Lautenberg Act | The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act, signed June 22, 2016, which amended TSCA;[5] EPA's 2024 rule cites Congress's intent to "delete the paralyzing 'least burdensome' requirement".[2] |
| Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA | No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.), consolidated with Nos. 24-60281 and 24-60333: the challenges to the 2024 rule by chemical-industry associations and by public-health, scientific, firefighter and labor petitioners;[6] argued June 1, 2026 before Judges Clement, Southwick and Engelhardt; no decision posted as of October 16, 2026.[11] |
| East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA | No. 24-60227 consolidated with No. 24-60256 (5th Cir. September 15, 2026), opinion by Judge Edith H. Jones for a panel of Judges Higginbotham, Jones and Southwick: vacated EPA's 2024 methylene chloride rule and its associated risk determination.[12] |
| The Fifth Circuit | The federal appeals court that decided Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp. on September 10, 1973,[18] Corrosion Proof Fittings in 1991,[4] and East Fork in 2026,[12] and that holds the challenge to the 2024 rule. See Borel_v._Fibreboard. |
| Rod De Llano | Described in this episode's third sponsor message as a founding partner at Danziger & De Llano who began his career on the defense side at a large firm, defending corporations in product-liability cases. |
| Danziger & De Llano, LLP | National mesothelioma law firm; over $2 billion recovered for families nationwide.[17] Featured sponsor. |
Cases and Legal Frameworks
- EPA, Asbestos Part 1: Chrysotile Asbestos, 89 Fed. Reg. 21970 (March 28, 2024) — TSCA section 6(a) rule; import of chrysotile for chlor-alkali diaphragms prohibited as of May 28, 2024; staggered phase-outs to calendar year 2037.[2][1]
- Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp., 493 F.2d 1076 (5th Cir. September 10, 1973) — The Fifth Circuit's asbestos product-liability decision the episode names in its opening.[18]
- Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. October 18, 1991) — Vacated and remanded the 1989 rule (54 Fed. Reg. 29,460); "least burdensome requirements".[4]
- Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act (signed June 22, 2016) — Amended TSCA.[5]
- Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.) — EPA's June 16, 2025 abeyance motion and its July 7, 2025 withdrawal;[7] the industry petitioners' May 19, 2026 withdrawal of one issue;[6] argued June 1, 2026; no decision posted as of October 16, 2026.[11]
- Olin Corporation v. EPA, No. 24-60333 (5th Cir.) — Dismissed with prejudice by stipulation, May 6, 2026.[8]
- East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA, Nos. 24-60227 and 24-60256 (5th Cir. September 15, 2026) — Methylene chloride rule and risk determination vacated; remanded.[12]
- Olin Corporation, TSCA section 6(g) exemption petition — Seeks two additional years beyond the May 28, 2029 compliance deadline.[3]
Key Facts and Statistics
- March 18 / March 28 / May 28, 2024 — the rule announced, published (89 Fed. Reg. 21970) and effective.[1][2]
- 1 of 6 — chrysotile among the fiber types in TSCA's definition of asbestos.[2]
- 5 / 8 / 12 years — chlor-alkali phase-outs for a company converting a first, second and third facility to membrane technology.[1]
- 2 years / 5 years / through 2037 — most sheet gaskets; titanium dioxide and nuclear-material gaskets; Savannah River Site gaskets.[1]
- 6 months — oilfield brake blocks, aftermarket brakes and linings, other vehicle friction products and other gaskets.[1]
- 7 years, then 2 more — Olin's proposed timeline that EPA rejected,[2] and its later request for two additional years beyond May 28, 2029.[3]
- 1979 → 1989 → 1991 — EPA begins its TSCA asbestos proceedings, the rule issues, and the Fifth Circuit vacates it.[4]
- June 22, 2016 — the Lautenberg Act signed.[5]
- February 14, 2025: 120 days — the court's first hold on the case, for new agency leadership to review the rule.[7]
- June 16 and July 7, 2025 — EPA's motion for six more months, and its withdrawal.[7] According to a law-firm summary of EPA's motion, EPA estimated that a new rulemaking could take up to thirty months.[15]
- May 6 and May 19, 2026 — Olin's stipulation to dismiss its petition; the industry petitioners withdraw their worst-case-assumptions issue.[8][6]
- June 1, 2026 — oral argument in Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, after the panel asked counsel to address standing.[9]
- September 15, 2026 — East Fork: methylene chloride rule and risk determination vacated.[12]
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| September 10, 1973 | The Fifth Circuit decides Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp.[18] |
| 1979 | EPA begins TSCA proceedings on asbestos with an advance notice of proposed rulemaking[4] |
| July 12, 1989 | EPA issues its rule to prohibit asbestos in almost all products[4] |
| October 18, 1991 | Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA: the Fifth Circuit vacates and remands the 1989 rule[4] |
| November 15, 2000 | EPA publishes a narrower asbestos worker-protection rule for state and local government workers[12] |
| June 22, 2016 | The Lautenberg Act amends TSCA[5] |
| April 4, 2023 | Olin proposes a seven-year timeline for chlor-alkali conversions[2] |
| March 18, 2024 | EPA announces the final chrysotile rule[1] |
| March 28, 2024 | The rule is published at 89 Fed. Reg. 21970[2] |
| May 28, 2024 | The rule takes effect; import of chrysotile for chlor-alkali diaphragms is prohibited[2] |
| February 14, 2025 | The Fifth Circuit holds the case in abeyance for 120 days so new EPA leadership can review the rule[7] |
| June 16, 2025 | EPA asks for six more months to reconsider the rule through new rulemaking[7] |
| July 7, 2025 | EPA withdraws the motion and says it no longer intends to conduct a new rulemaking at this time[7] |
| May 6, 2026 | Olin and EPA file a stipulation to dismiss Olin's petition with prejudice (clerk's order May 15, 2026)[8][11] |
| May 19, 2026 | Industry petitioners withdraw their worst-case-assumptions issue and do not seek vacatur of EPA's risk evaluation[6] |
| May 27, 2026 | The panel asks counsel to be prepared to discuss standing at argument[9] |
| June 1, 2026 | Oral argument in Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA[11] |
| June 2, 2026 | The court requests letter briefs on standing and on whether each petition must be dismissed[10] |
| September 15, 2026 | East Fork Enterprises v. EPA: the methylene chloride rule and its risk determination are vacated[12] |
| October 16, 2026 | No decision in the challenge has been posted; the 2024 rule remains in effect[11] |
| May 28, 2029 | Five-year chlor-alkali compliance deadline[3] |
| 2037 | Savannah River Site gasket allowance ends (through calendar year 2037)[1] |
References
- ↑ 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.29 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, "Biden-Harris Administration Finalizes Ban on Ongoing Uses of Asbestos to Protect People from Cancer," news release (March 18, 2024). Chrysotile is "the only known form of asbestos currently used in or imported to the United States"; the ban "is the first rule to be finalized under the 2016 amendments"; chlor-alkali companies converting multiple facilities get "five years to convert their first facility, eight years to convert their second and 12 years to convert their third"; most sheet gaskets are banned two years after the effective date, with five-year phase-outs for titanium dioxide production and nuclear-material processing and use "through CY 2037 at the Department of Energy's Savannah River Site"; oilfield brake blocks, aftermarket automotive brakes and linings, other vehicle friction products and other gaskets are banned six months after the effective date; other fiber types and legacy uses are addressed in part 2 of the risk evaluation.
- ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 2.19 2.20 2.21 2.22 2.23 2.24 2.25 2.26 2.27 2.28 2.29 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, "Asbestos Part 1; Chrysotile Asbestos; Regulation of Certain Conditions of Use Under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)," final rule, 89 Fed. Reg. 21970 (published March 28, 2024; effective May 28, 2024). Quotes TSCA's definition of asbestos as "Asbestiform varieties of six fiber types"; says EPA "assessed these non-legacy conditions of use of chrysotile asbestos" and is addressing legacy uses and associated disposal in Part 2; states "The only form of asbestos manufactured (including imported), processed, or distributed for use in the United States today is chrysotile asbestos" and calls chrysotile "a known human carcinogen"; prohibits manufacture (including import) of chrysotile for chlor-alkali diaphragms as of the effective date, with processing and use prohibited five years after it and allowances to eight and 12 years under § 751.505(c)–(d); records that the 2016 amendments reflect Congressional intent to "delete the paralyzing 'least burdensome' requirement" (citing 162 Cong. Rec. S3517, June 7, 2016); ties the Savannah River Site date to "completion of the liquid waste program at SRS by the end of 2037"; and (at 89 Fed. Reg. 21980–81) records Olin's April 4, 2023 letter supporting a ban on "new or replacement asbestos-based diaphragms in two years, in combination with an additional five years to operate any existing asbestos-based diaphragm production cells," which EPA found did not establish "that seven years is as soon as practicable".
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 Olin Corporation, "Petition Under Section 6(g) of the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) for a Time-Limited Exemption from the Compliance Deadline in the 2024 Asbestos Part 1 Rule for Chrysotile Asbestos," petition to the EPA Administrator, posted by EPA, PDF. "Olin requests an additional two years to convert its facilities from using asbestos diaphragm cells to using non-asbestos diaphragms," beyond "the compliance deadline of May 28, 2029"; describes Olin as "the largest global and U.S. producer of chlor-alkali and the owner of the largest global and U.S. asbestos-based diaphragm chlor-alkali facility"; states that Olin filed a petition for review of the Final Rule; projects completing its transition by May 2031. The company's own filing.
- ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 4.10 4.11 4.12 4.13 Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. Oct. 18, 1991) (Public.Resource.Org copy). "The EPA began these proceedings in 1979"; the 1989 rule (54 Fed. Reg. 29,460) would "prohibit the future manufacture, importation, processing, and distribution of asbestos in almost all products"; TSCA required "the least burdensome requirements"; "We therefore GRANT the petition for review, VACATE the EPA's proposed regulation, and REMAND"; part V.D held EPA may "ban products that once were, but no longer are, being produced in the United States," and the clarification holds that this "applies only to products that were not being manufactured, imported, or processed on July 12, 1989, the date of the rule's promulgation".
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, "The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act." "On June 22, 2016, the Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act (Lautenberg Chemical Safety Act) was signed into law. The Lautenberg Chemical Safety Act amends the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)".
- ↑ 6.00 6.01 6.02 6.03 6.04 6.05 6.06 6.07 6.08 6.09 "Industry Petitioners' Notice of Withdrawal of Issue," Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.), Doc. 321 (dated May 19, 2026), PDF (RECAP archive copy). The Texas, American, Georgia and Ohio chemistry councils withdraw the issue "whether EPA's Risk Evaluation, on which the Final Rule is premised, fails the substantial evidence standard because it is based on worst-case assumptions and not actual conditions of use, thereby overestimating risk," will not argue it, and "do not seek vacatur of EPA's Risk Evaluation"; their other issues are that the rule "exceeds EPA's authority under section 9" because EPA did not refer its findings to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, and that it "imposes measures beyond 'the extent necessary'" without "any real alternative regulatory action other than a ban"; notes Olin dismissed its petition on May 6, 2026, that "Key compliance deadlines impacting Industry Petitioners' member companies have already passed," including the interim exposure limit for chlor-alkali facilities starting November 25, 2024, and that the associations intervened to defend other aspects of the rule "against challenges raised by non-industry petitioners." The caption lists the public-health, physician-scientist, firefighter-local and United Steelworkers petitioners. The industry petitioners' filing.
- ↑ 7.00 7.01 7.02 7.03 7.04 7.05 7.06 7.07 7.08 7.09 7.10 7.11 EPA, "Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Hold Case in Abeyance," Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, Nos. 24-60193, 24-60281, 24-60333 (5th Cir.), Doc. 213-1 (filed July 7, 2025), PDF (RECAP archive copy). "On February 14, 2025, the Court granted EPA's Motion to Hold Case In Abeyance for 120 days to allow new Agency leadership to review the challenged rule regulating asbestos"; "On June 16, 2025, EPA filed a Motion to Hold Case In Abeyance for an additional six months while the Agency reconsiders the challenged rule via notice-and-comment rulemaking"; "In lieu of a reply, EPA is withdrawing the Motion"; "the Agency has further reconsidered the challenged rule and no longer intends to conduct notice-and-comment rulemaking to evaluate potential changes at this time"; asks the court to set an August 8, 2025 deadline for motions to govern further proceedings. Filed by EPA as respondent.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 "Stipulation to Dismiss," Olin Corporation v. EPA, No. 24-60333 (5th Cir.), Doc. 313 (filed May 6, 2026), PDF (RECAP archive copy). Olin and EPA "stipulate that the above petition, No. 24-60333, shall be dismissed with prejudice"; the stipulation "does not relate to the other petitions consolidated with this one, Nos. 24-60193 & 24-60281."
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 Clerk's letter to counsel, Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.), Doc. 326 (May 27, 2026), PDF (RECAP archive copy). "The oral argument panel requests that counsel be prepared to discuss at oral argument on 6/1/26, the following: Whether Petitioners have satisfied their burdens of establishing standing, including whether Petitioners have sufficiently articulated their alleged injuries in fact and adequately supported their claims."
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 Clerk's letter to counsel, Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.), Doc. 333 (June 2, 2026), PDF (RECAP archive copy). "The court wishes to receive simultaneous letters briefs from the parties on issues relevant to the petitioners' standing. Those issues include how standing must be shown, whether it has been shown here, and if not, whether each petition for review must be dismissed." Briefs due June 10, 2026.
- ↑ 11.00 11.01 11.02 11.03 11.04 11.05 11.06 11.07 11.08 11.09 11.10 11.11 Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir.), consolidated with Nos. 24-60281 and 24-60333, docket entries as read October 16, 2026 (RECAP copy of the PACER docket): order granting EPA's motion to stay proceedings (February 2025); EPA's opposed motion to extend the stay (June 2025) and court action withdrawing it, with the stay extended through August 8, 2025 (entered July 9, 2025); order lifting the stay (November 24, 2025); joint stipulation by Olin and EPA to dismiss Olin's petition, No. 24-60333 (filed May 6, 2026), and the clerk's order granting the dismissal (docket entry 318, May 15, 2026); oral argument heard June 1, 2026 before Judges Clement, Southwick and Engelhardt, after a panel request that counsel be prepared to discuss "whether Petitioners have satisfied their burdens of establishing standing"; supplemental briefs on standing (June 10, 2026). As measured October 16, 2026: no opinion in No. 24-60193 at the Fifth Circuit's published or unpublished opinion addresses (both 404, against a 200 for the court's East Fork opinion), and the newest RECAP docket entry is No. 357 of June 22, 2026; the RECAP copy can lag the court's own docket. EPA and its Administrator are the respondents.
- ↑ 12.00 12.01 12.02 12.03 12.04 12.05 12.06 12.07 12.08 12.09 12.10 12.11 12.12 12.13 12.14 East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA, No. 24-60227 c/w No. 24-60256 (5th Cir. filed September 15, 2026), PDF. Before Higginbotham, Jones and Southwick, Circuit Judges; opinion by Judge Jones. "[W]e GRANT the Industry Petitioners' petition for review, VACATE EPA's Rule and associated risk determination, DENY the Sierra Club's petition for review, and REMAND"; "the risk analysis did not accord with the best available science as the TSCA requires"; recounts that the court vacated EPA's 1989 asbestos rule in Corrosion Proof Fittings and that "Almost a decade later, EPA published a narrower asbestos rule aimed at protecting state and local government workers" (65 Fed. Reg. 69210, Nov. 15, 2000).
- ↑ Danziger & De Llano: Mesothelioma and Asbestos Lawyers, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Asbestos Trust Fund Database of documented U.S. asbestos bankruptcy trusts: "Payment percentages, net assets, and source confidence ratings," with each source classified as a filed court document, a secondary source citing a primary, or an estimate; "Data updated weekly from trust websites and court filings." It is built by the team behind this podcast. AsbestosTrusts.org — Trust Directory
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 Ogletree Deakins, "EPA's 2024 Asbestos Ban Paused as Fifth Circuit Grants Abeyance for Rule Reconsideration" (July 2, 2025). Reports that EPA's June 16, 2025 motion "indicated that this process, including public comment and stakeholder engagement, could take up to thirty months." The post also reports the six-month abeyance as granted; EPA's July 7, 2025 notice of withdrawal (cited on this page) shows the motion was withdrawn before any ruling.
- ↑ World Health Organization, Chrysotile Asbestos (2014), PDF. "No threshold has been identified for the carcinogenic risk of asbestos, including chrysotile."
- ↑ 17.0 17.1 About Us, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ 18.0 18.1 18.2 Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp., 493 F.2d 1076 (5th Cir. Sept. 10, 1973) (Public.Resource.Org copy).
External Links
Primary Sources
- EPA final rule, 89 Fed. Reg. 21970 (2024)
- EPA news release on the final rule, March 18, 2024
- Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. 1991)
- East Fork Enterprises, Inc. v. EPA (5th Cir. September 15, 2026)
- Olin Corporation TSCA section 6(g) exemption petition
- The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act (EPA)
Compensation and Legal Help
- AsbestosTrusts.org — every active asbestos trust: what it holds, what it pays, what it requires
- Mesothelioma Compensation — Danziger & De Llano
- Asbestos Exposure — Danziger & De Llano
- Danziger & De Llano, LLP
Series Navigation
| Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making — Arc 9: The Ongoing Cover-Up | ||
|---|---|---|
| Previous: Episode 46: The Talc Connection | Episode 47: The Ban That Finally Came | Next: Episode 48: The Hidden Asbestos |
Related Wiki Pages
- Asbestos_Podcast_EP46_Transcript — The Talc Connection: the previous episode, whose closing teases this one
- Asbestos_Podcast_EP39_Transcript — Corrosion Proof Fittings and the 1989 ban, the episode this one asks listeners to hold in mind
- EPA_Chrysotile_Asbestos_Ban_2024 — The 2024 rule and its litigation
- EPA_Asbestos_Ban_1989_Court_Reversal — The 1989 ban and the 1991 decision
- U.S._Asbestos_Ban_History_and_Regulations — Federal asbestos regulation over time
- Alan_Reinstein_Ban_Asbestos_Now_Act — Proposed legislation for a complete ban
- Borel_v._Fibreboard — The 1973 Fifth Circuit decision named in the episode's opening
- Asbestos_Trust_Funds — Compensation mechanisms and the trust fund filing process
- Mesothelioma_Latency_Period — Why asbestos disease appears decades after exposure
- Asbestos_History_Timeline — Full chronological history of asbestos knowledge, use, and litigation
- The_Asbestos_Podcast — Main podcast page with all episodes
About This Series
Asbestos: A Conspiracy 4,500 Years in the Making is a 52-episode documentary podcast tracing the complete history of asbestos from 4700 BCE to the 2024 EPA ban. The series is produced by Danziger & De Llano, LLP, a nationwide mesothelioma law firm with over 30 years of experience.
Episode 47 is the fifth and final episode of Arc 9 ("The Ongoing Cover-Up"): the 2024 federal chrysotile rule, the 1991 decision it had to overcome, and the challenge pending in the same court. Episode 48, The Hidden Asbestos, opens the final arc with the asbestos already in buildings.