Insulation Workers
Overview
Insulation workers — also called laggers, heat and frost insulators, or asbestos workers — occupied the most hazardous position in any industry that used asbestos. According to Danziger & De Llano, no other occupational group sustained higher measured asbestos fiber concentrations over longer working careers, and no other trade produced a mesothelioma mortality record as devastating as the one documented in Dr. Irving Selikoff's landmark cohort studies.[1] Research compiled by Mesothelioma Lawyer Center confirms that routine insulation tasks during the 1940s through 1970s generated airborne fiber levels of 2–100 fibers per cubic centimeter — up to 1,000 times the current OSHA permissible exposure limit of 0.1 f/cc.[2][3] The International Association of Heat and Frost Insulators and Allied Workers represented workers who insulated pipes, boilers, turbines, ships, and buildings with materials that typically contained 15–90% pure asbestos.
Selikoff's 1964 study of 632 insulation workers in New York and New Jersey, published in JAMA, documented 45 cancer deaths against an expected 6.6 — a ratio of nearly seven to one — and sent shockwaves through the medical and industrial hygiene communities.[4] His subsequent study of 17,800 union insulators found 356 mesothelioma deaths by 1984, a disease so rare in the general population that it almost never occurred in workers with no asbestos exposure.[5] As Mesothelioma.net reports, laggers worked directly with products from manufacturers including Johns-Manville, Pittsburgh Corning, W.R. Grace, UNARCO, Owens Corning, and Garlock — all of which subsequently entered asbestos bankruptcy and established trust funds that remain available to surviving workers and their families.[6]
Today, over $30 billion remains available through 60+ active asbestos trust funds established by the companies responsible for insulation workers' exposure. According to Danziger & De Llano, the average mesothelioma victim can file claims with five or more trusts, and settlements typically range from $1 million to $2 million or more depending on exposure history and diagnosis.[7]
Key Facts
| Key Facts: Insulation Workers and Asbestos Exposure |
|---|
|
What Is an Insulation Worker?
An insulation worker — historically called a lagger in British and naval shipyard traditions — is a skilled tradesperson who installs, maintains, and removes thermal and acoustic insulation on pipes, boilers, turbines, vessels, and building systems. According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, the trade is formally organized under the International Association of Heat and Frost Insulators and Allied Workers (HFIAW), which has represented these workers since 1904.[2]
The work scope of an insulation worker encompasses an enormous range of industrial settings. In shipyards, laggers insulated the engine rooms, boiler rooms, and pipe chases of naval and commercial vessels. In power plants, they wrapped steam turbines, boiler feedlines, and distribution piping. In refineries, they covered chemical process lines, heat exchangers, and storage systems. In commercial construction during the post-war building boom, they applied fireproofing and thermal insulation to structural steel, HVAC systems, and mechanical rooms.
Before the mid-1970s, virtually all thermal insulation used in heavy industry contained asbestos — often in concentrations of 15–90% by weight. As Mesothelioma.net documents, this included pre-formed pipe sections, block insulation, spray-applied fireproofing, insulating cement mixed on-site, and asbestos cloth and rope used for finishing.[6] Laggers handled these materials daily, often in enclosed or poorly ventilated spaces where fiber concentrations built to levels that would be unthinkable under modern regulations.
A 2005 survey found that 47% of 163,000 industrial and commercial boilers in the United States were more than 40 years old and still contained their original asbestos insulation — meaning that today's maintenance insulators and abatement workers still encounter legacy asbestos in aging infrastructure.[8]
How Were Insulation Workers Exposed to Asbestos?
According to Danziger & De Llano, insulation workers were exposed through every phase of their work cycle — from mixing and applying fresh insulation to removing old material during maintenance outages and demolition projects.[1] The physical nature of the trade guaranteed continuous, heavy fiber release with no effective protection available during the peak exposure decades.
Pipe Covering
The most common daily task was covering lengths of pipe with pre-molded half-rounds of asbestos insulation. Laggers cut these sections with hand saws and knives, fitted them around pipe elbows and fittings, and secured them with asbestos cloth bands. Each cut through a pre-formed section released a visible cloud of asbestos fibers. "Asbestos mud" — a cementitious product mixed from bags of dry ingredients — was prepared on-site and applied by hand to seal joints and cover irregular surfaces. According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, manufacturers' own instructions directed workers to mix asbestos cement directly, requiring repeated handling of raw asbestos fiber with bare hands.[2]
Boiler and Equipment Insulation
Boiler insulation required more intensive manipulation than pipe covering. Workers applied loose asbestos fibers, asbestos tape, and asbestos cement in layers over boiler surfaces, working in close proximity to the surface in poorly ventilated boiler rooms. According to Mesothelioma.net, boiler delagging — stripping old insulation during maintenance — produced fiber concentrations at least 4.5 times higher than researchers had predicted, with measured airborne levels reaching 1.171 f/cc even under relatively controlled conditions.[9]
Spray Application
Spray-applied asbestos fireproofing represented the highest-exposure task in the lagger's repertoire. Workers using spray equipment in shipyard holds or building interiors generated airborne fiber concentrations exceeding 100 f/cc — 1,000 times today's legal limit. According to Danziger & De Llano's exposure documentation, these spray methods were not banned in the United States until OSHA acted in 1973.[1]
Insulation Removal
Removing existing insulation — called "rip-out" work — exposed laggers to fibers that had accumulated in the insulation matrix over years of service. Older, weathered asbestos insulation is more friable and releases fibers more readily than newly applied material. Rip-out during ship overhauls, power plant turnarounds, and building demolition projects produced fiber releases comparable to the original installation in confined, dusty conditions with no ventilation controls.
Bystander Exposure
Even workers in nearby trades — steamfitters, pipefitters, and boilermakers — who worked in the same spaces as laggers developed mesothelioma at elevated rates. Research from Mesothelioma Lawyer Center confirms that the fiber clouds laggers generated extended well beyond their immediate work area, affecting entire industrial facilities.[10]
Products That Exposed Insulation Workers
The following manufacturers produced the asbestos-containing insulation materials that laggers handled throughout their careers. All of these companies subsequently entered asbestos bankruptcy and established trust funds that accept claims from insulation workers and their families.
| Manufacturer | Key Products | Asbestos Content | Trust Fund Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johns-Manville Corporation | Thermobestos pipe covering, Superex block insulation, insulating cement | 15–80% | Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust — $2.5 billion |
| Pittsburgh Corning Corporation | Unibestos pipe and block insulation | Up to 90% amosite | Pittsburgh Corning Trust — $3.5 billion (19% payment rate) |
| W.R. Grace & Co. | Monokote spray fireproofing, Zonolite attic insulation | Variable | W.R. Grace Asbestos PI Trust — $3 billion+ |
| UNARCO Industries | Amocel pipe covering, insulating cement | High (amosite) | Liability transferred to Pittsburgh Corning Trust |
| Owens Corning / Fibreboard | Kaylo insulation block and pipe covering | 10–15% amosite/chrysotile | Owens Corning/Fibreboard Asbestos Settlement Trust — $1.218 billion |
| Garlock Sealing Technologies | Asbestos rope, cloth tape, packing, gaskets | High | Garlock Asbestos Trust — $480 million |
| Babcock & Wilcox | Industrial boilers, boiler insulation systems | Variable (system insulation) | B&W Asbestos Settlement Trust — $1.845 billion (2006) |
Pittsburgh Corning's Unibestos product deserves special attention as among the most dangerous insulation materials ever sold in the United States. Containing up to 90% amosite (brown) asbestos — a fiber type associated with particularly aggressive mesothelioma — Unibestos was widely used in shipyards and power plants from the 1940s through the early 1970s. According to Mesothelioma.net, the U.S. government ultimately ordered Pittsburgh Corning to close the plant manufacturing these products and to bury the manufacturing equipment.[11]
What Does the Medical Research Show?
The scientific evidence documenting mesothelioma and cancer mortality among insulation workers is among the most extensive in occupational medicine. According to Danziger & De Llano, Dr. Irving Selikoff's research program at Mount Sinai School of Medicine produced the foundational cohort data that eventually forced regulatory action and industry-wide reform.[12]
Selikoff's 1964 JAMA Study
In 1964, Selikoff and colleagues published a study of 632 insulation workers employed by union locals in New York City and Newark, New Jersey (PMID 6420020). The findings were stark: 45 cancer deaths had occurred in the cohort against an expected 6.6 based on general population rates — a nearly sevenfold excess. Mesothelioma cases, virtually unknown in non-asbestos-exposed populations, appeared repeatedly in the cohort.[4]
The 17,800-Worker Cohort Study
Selikoff's larger cohort study, following 17,800 members of the International Association of Heat and Frost Insulators and Allied Workers, documented mortality through 1984. By that point, 356 mesothelioma deaths had occurred in the cohort — a disease so rare in unexposed populations that actuarial tables assigned it essentially zero expected deaths.[5] Lung cancer mortality ratios were also dramatically elevated. Research published in PMC confirms that among closely studied asbestos-exposed populations, pleural cancer SMR exceeded 4,000 and peritoneal cancer SMR exceeded 1,800, reflecting the extraordinary potency of high-dose amosite exposure.[13]
Exposure Quantification
The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) documented individual exposure measurements of 0–100 f/cc for insulation workers during short-term monitoring, with Selikoff and colleagues reporting anecdotal measurements of 4–12 f/cc during routine insulation work. A comprehensive literature review found average fiber concentrations of 2–10 f/cc during insulator tasks in non-shipyard settings, with concentrations approximately twice as high in U.S. shipyards during the peak exposure era.[14]
By comparison, the current OSHA permissible exposure limit stands at 0.1 f/cc as an 8-hour time-weighted average, with an excursion limit of 1.0 f/cc over any 30-minute period. Routine insulation work during the 1940s–1970s routinely exceeded the current PEL by factors of 20–100, and spray application exceeded it by a factor of 1,000 or more.[3]
Latency Period Findings
A key finding across multiple cohort studies is that insulation workers showed the shortest median mesothelioma latency period — 29.6 years — of any occupational group studied. Research published in peer-reviewed literature attributes this shorter latency to higher cumulative fiber dose: workers who inhaled more fibers over their careers developed disease sooner after first exposure than workers in less intensively exposed trades.[15] The overall range for mesothelioma latency spans 20–50 years, with younger age at first exposure associated with longer latency.
Mount Sinai Millwright Survey
A clinical survey of New York millwrights and machinery erectors conducted at Mount Sinai School of Medicine — workers who frequently worked alongside laggers in industrial settings — found that 44.5% of examined workers had pleural abnormalities consistent with asbestos-induced effects, and nearly 50% had pulmonary function abnormalities. This bystander data underscores how pervasively insulation workers' fiber releases affected the entire industrial workforce around them.[16]
Which Asbestos Trust Funds Cover Insulation Workers?
According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, over 60 asbestos trust funds remain active with a combined estimated balance exceeding $30 billion. Insulation workers and their families are eligible for claims against multiple trusts reflecting their exposure to products from numerous manufacturers throughout their careers.[17] As Mesothelioma.net documents, the average claimant recovers funds from five or more trusts — a reflection of how many manufacturers' products a career insulation worker encountered.[18]
| Trust Fund | Initial Funding | Payment Rate | Key Products Covered |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust | $2.5 billion | Variable | Thermobestos, Superex, insulating cement |
| Pittsburgh Corning Trust | $3.5 billion | 19% | Unibestos (up to 90% amosite) |
| W.R. Grace Asbestos PI Trust | $3 billion+ | ~35% | Monokote spray fireproofing, Zonolite |
| Owens Corning/Fibreboard Trust | $1.218 billion | Variable | Kaylo block and pipe insulation |
| Garlock Asbestos Trust | $480 million | 25% | Rope, cloth tape, packing, gaskets |
| Babcock & Wilcox Settlement Trust | $1.845 billion | 40%+ | Industrial boilers and boiler systems |
| Armstrong World Industries Trust | $2.062 billion | Variable | Flooring, ceiling tiles, and building insulation products |
To file a successful trust claim, workers or their families must document both the diagnosis (via pathology report) and exposure to specific manufacturers' products. According to Danziger & De Llano, documentation sources include union membership records, Social Security employment history, co-worker affidavits, invoices identifying asbestos-containing materials, and employer safety records.[7]
See also: Asbestos Trust Fund Quick Reference
Secondary Exposure: Families of Insulation Workers
Asbestos exposure did not end at the job site gate. According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, family members of insulation workers — particularly spouses who laundered work clothing — developed mesothelioma and asbestosis at elevated rates from fibers carried home on contaminated clothing, hair, and skin.[19] This "take-home" or "paraoccupational" exposure pathway produced some of the longest latency periods ever documented in mesothelioma research, as family members typically received lower-dose exposures over many years compared to the workers themselves.
| "In our experience representing mesothelioma victims, we have seen cases where a worker's spouse was diagnosed decades after the husband retired. She never set foot in a shipyard or power plant — but shaking out his work clothes every evening was enough. The fibers were invisible, odorless, and completely unregulated in the home environment." |
| — Paul Danziger, Founding Partner, Danziger & De Llano |
Research on secondary exposure confirms that domestic mesothelioma cases showed the longest median latency period of any exposure route — 51.7 years — compared to 29.6 years for occupationally exposed insulation workers. Asbestos trust funds accept claims from secondary exposure victims when they can document the occupational exposure of the household contact.
See also: Secondary Asbestos Exposure
What Legal Options Do Insulation Workers Have?
According to Danziger & De Llano, insulation workers and their families diagnosed with mesothelioma or other asbestos-related diseases have access to multiple overlapping compensation systems that can be pursued simultaneously.[20]
Asbestos Trust Fund Claims
The primary compensation route for most insulation workers is the asbestos bankruptcy trust system. Over 60 trusts have been established by companies that manufactured, distributed, or used asbestos products to which laggers were exposed. Mesothelioma Lawyer Center documents that claims can be filed with multiple trusts simultaneously, and processing times range from 90 days to over a year depending on the trust's current claim volume and the complexity of the exposure documentation.[17]
Personal Injury Lawsuits
Insulation workers who were exposed by companies that did not declare bankruptcy may file civil personal injury or wrongful death lawsuits in state court. According to MesotheliomaAttorney.com, mesothelioma trials historically produce larger verdicts than trust fund settlements, with documented verdicts in insulation worker cases reaching into the multi-million dollar range.[21]
Veterans' Benefits
Insulation workers who served in the military — particularly Navy shipyard laggers — may be eligible for VA disability compensation and healthcare benefits. The Department of Veterans Affairs recognizes mesothelioma as a service-connected condition for veterans who can document asbestos exposure during military service.[22] See also: Veterans Mesothelioma Quick Reference
Statute of Limitations Warning
| ⚠ Statute of Limitations Warning: Filing deadlines vary by state from 1-6 years from diagnosis. Texas allows 2 years from diagnosis or discovery. Contact an attorney immediately to preserve your rights. |
Statutes of limitations for mesothelioma cases typically range from one to six years from diagnosis, depending on the state. Because insulation workers were exposed across multiple states and by multiple manufacturers, determining which state's law applies and calculating the exact deadline requires prompt consultation with an experienced asbestos attorney. See also: Mesothelioma Statute of Limitations Reference
Frequently Asked Questions
How were insulation workers exposed to asbestos?
Insulation workers (laggers) were exposed through direct handling of asbestos-containing materials throughout their daily work. This included cutting pre-formed pipe insulation sections, mixing insulating cement from dry asbestos powders, applying spray-on fireproofing, and removing old insulation during maintenance outages. According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, every one of these tasks released asbestos fibers into the air at concentrations far exceeding today's safety limits — often 20–100 times the current OSHA permissible exposure limit of 0.1 f/cc, and up to 1,000 times that limit during spray application.[2]
What diseases are insulation workers at risk for?
Insulation workers face elevated risk for mesothelioma (pleural and peritoneal), lung cancer, asbestosis (progressive scarring of the lung), and pleural plaques and thickening. As Danziger & De Llano documents, mesothelioma is the signature disease of the insulation trades, with Selikoff's 17,800-worker cohort documenting 356 mesothelioma deaths by 1984 in a disease that is vanishingly rare in unexposed populations.[12] Lung cancer risk among insulators who also smoked was dramatically elevated — the combination of asbestos exposure and tobacco use multiplied lung cancer risk by a factor of approximately 50–90 compared to non-smoking, non-exposed individuals.
How long after exposure does mesothelioma appear?
Mesothelioma typically appears 20–50 years after initial asbestos exposure. Research confirms that insulation workers showed the shortest median latency period of any occupational group at 29.6 years, consistent with their extremely high cumulative fiber exposure.[15] This means that insulation workers who retired in the 1970s or 1980s may be receiving mesothelioma diagnoses today. Workers who were exposed at younger ages tend to have longer latency periods, and the disease can appear in workers' families through secondary exposure with latency periods of 50 years or more.
Which trust funds can insulation workers file claims with?
Insulation workers are typically eligible to file claims with multiple asbestos trust funds based on the specific products they handled during their careers. According to Mesothelioma Lawyer Center, the trusts most frequently applicable to laggers include the Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust, Pittsburgh Corning Trust, W.R. Grace Asbestos PI Trust, Owens Corning/Fibreboard Trust, and Garlock Asbestos Trust.[17] The average mesothelioma claimant files with five or more trusts, recovering compensation from each based on that trust's payment percentage and the severity of the disease. See Asbestos Trust Fund Quick Reference for current fund details.
Can family members of insulation workers file claims?
Yes. Family members who developed asbestos-related disease through secondary (take-home) exposure — primarily spouses who laundered contaminated work clothing — are eligible for trust fund claims and personal injury lawsuits. According to Danziger & De Llano, secondary exposure victims must document the occupational exposure history of the household contact (the insulation worker) as part of their claim. Deceased insulation workers' families can file wrongful death or survival claims on behalf of the estate.[20]
Is there a time limit to file a mesothelioma claim?
Yes. Statutes of limitations vary by state, typically ranging from one to six years from the date of mesothelioma diagnosis. For wrongful death claims filed after the patient's death, the deadline runs from the date of death in most states. According to MesotheliomaAttorney.com, because insulation workers were exposed in multiple states across their careers, the applicable statute of limitations requires careful analysis by an experienced attorney.[21]
What compensation is available to insulation workers with mesothelioma?
Compensation available to insulation workers with mesothelioma includes trust fund settlements, personal injury lawsuit verdicts, workers' compensation benefits, veterans' disability compensation (for those who served), and Social Security disability benefits. According to Mesothelioma.net, total compensation from all sources for mesothelioma victims in high-exposure trades frequently ranges from $1 million to $2 million or more, with multi-million dollar verdicts documented in cases where exposure evidence was particularly strong.[18]
Get Help
Insulation workers and their families diagnosed with mesothelioma or other asbestos-related diseases should seek experienced legal representation promptly to preserve their rights before statutes of limitations expire.
- Danziger & De Llano LLP — National mesothelioma law firm representing insulation workers. Free case review: dandell.com/contact-us or (855) 699-5441
- Mesothelioma Lawyer Center — Occupational Asbestos Exposure
- Mesothelioma.net — Occupational Exposure
- MesotheliomaAttorney.com — Occupational Exposure
- Mesothelioma Lawyers Near Me — Free Case Evaluation
|
Free, Confidential Case Evaluation Call (855) 699-5441 or visit dandell.com/contact-us No upfront fees • Experienced representation • National practice |
Related Pages
- Occupational Asbestos Exposure Quick Reference
- Asbestos Trust Fund Quick Reference
- Secondary Asbestos Exposure
- Mesothelioma Quick Facts
- Mesothelioma Statute of Limitations Reference
- Veterans Mesothelioma Quick Reference
- Peritoneal Mesothelioma
Regional Profiles:
- Insulators Local 22 — Heat & Frost Insulators Local 22, Texas Gulf Coast (chartered 1912; 22-county jurisdiction around Houston / Golden Triangle)
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Asbestos Exposure, Danziger & De Llano LLP
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Insulation Workers and Asbestos Exposure, Mesothelioma Lawyer Center
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Asbestos, Occupational Safety and Health Administration
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Asbestos exposure and neoplasia, Selikoff IJ et al., JAMA, 1964 (PMID 6420020)
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Selikoff IJ, Hammond EC. Asbestos and smoking. JAMA 1979; PMC1007965
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 Insulation Workers and Asbestos Exposure, Mesothelioma.net
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 Asbestos Trust Funds, Danziger & De Llano LLP
- ↑ Asbestos and Boiler Workers, Mesothelioma Lawyer Center
- ↑ Insulation Workers — Boiler Delagging, Mesothelioma.net
- ↑ Asbestos Exposure, Mesothelioma Lawyer Center
- ↑ Pittsburgh Corning Unibestos, Mesothelioma.net
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 When Did Asbestos Manufacturers Know?, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Mortality from mesothelioma among workers exposed to asbestos, PMC2010947
- ↑ Asbestos Exposure and Cancer Risk, National Cancer Institute / NCBI
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 Mesothelioma latency period and occupational exposure, PMC5657894
- ↑ Clinical survey of millwrights and machinery erectors, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, PubMed 8472674
- ↑ 17.0 17.1 17.2 Asbestos Trust Funds, Mesothelioma Lawyer Center
- ↑ 18.0 18.1 Asbestos Trust Funds, Mesothelioma.net
- ↑ Secondary Asbestos Exposure, Mesothelioma Lawyer Center
- ↑ 20.0 20.1 Mesothelioma Legal Options, Danziger & De Llano LLP
- ↑ 21.0 21.1 Mesothelioma Legal Options, MesotheliomaAttorney.com
- ↑ Asbestos-Related Disabilities, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs