Brooklyn Navy Yard
Brooklyn Navy Yard: 71,000 Workers Exposed to Asbestos, 7x Mesothelioma Risk Documented (1806-1966)
Executive Summary
The Brooklyn Navy Yard, officially designated New York Naval Shipyard, operated as one of America's premier naval shipbuilding facilities from 1806 until its closure in 1966, and represents the largest documented single-site occupational asbestos exposure in United States history. Located on Wallabout Bay in Brooklyn, this 300-acre complex employed 71,000 workers at its World War II peak in 1944, making it New York City's largest employer during the war years. The facility constructed over 300 naval vessels including five battleships and numerous aircraft carriers, with each ship requiring tens to hundreds of tons of asbestos insulation installed by workers who received no protective equipment or health warnings.[1]
Dr. Irving Selikoff's landmark epidemiological study of 3,893 Brooklyn Navy Yard workers provided definitive scientific proof of the catastrophic health consequences of shipyard asbestos exposure. His research documented that workers developed mesothelioma at seven times the expected rate, with 11 mesothelioma deaths occurring compared to just 1.5 expected in the general population. Lung cancer deaths reached 89 compared to 55.4 expected, representing a 61% excess mortality that continues affecting workers and their families more than 40 years after the shipyard's closure.[2] According to Danziger & De Llano case documentation, shipyard workers exposed at Brooklyn Navy Yard during the 1940s through 1960s are still being diagnosed with mesothelioma today due to the disease's extended latency period of 20 to 50 years.
The facility's asbestos use began intensifying during World War I and reached extreme levels during World War II mobilization when production demands superseded any safety considerations. Workers in dedicated asbestos mixing rooms handled raw chrysotile and amosite fibers daily, creating insulation materials that were applied throughout vessels by insulators, pipefitters, boilermakers, electricians, and other trades. The accelerated wartime production schedule earned Brooklyn Navy Yard the nickname "Can-Do Shipyard" for completing major vessels ahead of schedule, but this achievement came at the cost of exposing tens of thousands of workers to lethal asbestos concentrations without respiratory protection.[3]
Secondary exposure through contaminated work clothing affected thousands of Brooklyn families who never entered the shipyard gates. Dr. Selikoff's research revealed that 11.3% of shipyard workers' wives showed radiographic evidence of asbestos-related lung changes from washing their husbands' work clothes, and children who embraced their fathers returning home faced exposure that would manifest as cancer decades later. This take-home exposure pattern established legal precedents that continue enabling family members to pursue compensation claims today.[4]
Workers exposed at Brooklyn Navy Yard and their families now have access to multiple compensation pathways including VA disability benefits for veterans, asbestos trust funds totaling over $30 billion, and civil litigation against companies that supplied asbestos products to the facility. Recent combined verdicts have reached $104 million for groups of Brooklyn Navy Yard workers, demonstrating courts' continued recognition of the preventable nature of these exposures and the profound suffering endured by victims.[5]
Key Facts
| Key Facts: Brooklyn Navy Yard Asbestos Exposure |
|---|
|
What Was the Brooklyn Navy Yard's Role in American Naval History?
The Brooklyn Navy Yard began operations in 1806 on the shores of Wallabout Bay, evolving from a small federal facility into what would become America's most productive shipbuilding complex during the 20th century. The shipyard's strategic location on the East River provided direct access to the Atlantic Ocean while offering the protected harbor conditions necessary for constructing the nation's largest warships. Throughout the 19th century, the facility pioneered American naval technology, building USS Fulton in 1815 as the nation's first steam-powered warship and establishing the technological foundation for over a century of subsequent steam propulsion development that would require extensive asbestos insulation.[6]
World War I marked the shipyard's transition into a major industrial facility when employment reached 18,000 workers constructing battleships and support vessels for the American Expeditionary Force. The interwar period saw substantial modernization of the facility's infrastructure, with new building ways and dry docks added to accommodate increasingly large warship designs. This expansion directly correlated with increased asbestos usage as steam systems became more complex and required greater quantities of thermal insulation throughout naval vessels.
| "The Brooklyn Navy Yard represents one of the most extensively documented cases of occupational asbestos exposure in American history. The facility's production records, combined with Dr. Selikoff's groundbreaking research, provide an extraordinarily complete picture of how workers were exposed and the health consequences they faced." |
| — Paul Danziger, Founding Partner, Danziger & De Llano |
World War II transformed the Brooklyn Navy Yard into an unprecedented industrial achievement and simultaneously created the largest mass asbestos exposure event at any single American facility. Employment exploded from 9,700 workers in 1940 to 71,000 by 1944 as the facility operated around the clock on three shifts to meet wartime production demands. The shipyard earned its "Can-Do Shipyard" reputation by completing major vessels ahead of schedule, including the battleship USS North Carolina in just 32 months and the aircraft carrier USS Bennington ahead of its contracted delivery date.[7]
The historic vessels constructed at Brooklyn Navy Yard read like a roster of American naval power. The battleship USS Arizona, completed at Brooklyn in 1916 and modernized there in the 1930s, carried extensive asbestos insulation that exposed construction workers and ultimately the sailors who died at Pearl Harbor in December 1941. USS Missouri, upon whose deck Japan signed the surrender documents ending World War II, was built by Brooklyn workers who installed asbestos throughout the ship's 887-foot length. Five battleships launched during World War II alone included USS North Carolina, USS Iowa, USS Missouri, USS Wisconsin, and USS New Jersey, each requiring thousands of tons of asbestos materials installed by unprotected workers.[8]
The post-war period brought continued asbestos exposure as the shipyard retrofitted World War II vessels for Cold War service and specialized in aircraft carrier modernization. Employment stabilized around 20,000 workers through the 1950s as the facility focused on nuclear vessel construction and supercarrier completion. The shipyard's final major construction project, the supercarrier USS Constellation completed in 1961, represented some of the most advanced steam propulsion technology ever installed in a naval vessel and required extensive asbestos insulation throughout its complex systems.
How Were Brooklyn Navy Yard Workers Exposed to Asbestos?
Workers at Brooklyn Navy Yard faced asbestos exposure through multiple pathways that created what industrial hygienists now recognize as one of the most contaminated occupational environments in American history. The shipyard maintained dedicated asbestos mixing rooms where workers combined raw asbestos fibers with water and cement to create the insulation materials used throughout naval vessels. These workers handled pure chrysotile and amosite asbestos daily, mixing batches of insulation compound while clouds of microscopic fibers contaminated not only their immediate work area but also spread through inadequate ventilation systems to adjacent departments throughout the sprawling facility.[9]
| ⚠ Important Documentation: Employment records, discharge papers, and work history documents from Brooklyn Navy Yard are crucial for establishing exposure claims. Workers and family members should preserve any documentation showing dates of employment, job titles, and work locations within the facility. |
Primary exposure occurred during new ship construction when insulators and laggers applied asbestos materials to steam pipes, boilers, turbines, and hull structures throughout vessels under construction. Each battleship required approximately 100 tons of asbestos insulation, while aircraft carriers needed substantially more due to their complex steam catapult launch systems and larger power plants. Workers cut asbestos boards with hand saws, releasing millions of microscopic fibers into confined below-deck spaces where ventilation was minimal or nonexistent. Pipefitters wrapped asbestos tape around joint connections, boilermakers lined fireboxes with asbestos bricks, and electricians pulled wiring through asbestos-lined conduits, creating trade-specific exposure patterns that varied in intensity but affected virtually every occupation within the shipyard.[10]
The most severe exposures occurred during ship overhaul and decommissioning operations when workers removed old asbestos insulation without protective equipment. This "rip-out" work generated asbestos concentrations exceeding 100 fibers per cubic centimeter, compared to today's permissible exposure limit of just 0.1 fibers per cubic centimeter. As documented by Mesothelioma Lawyer Center research, workers described conditions where asbestos dust was so thick that visibility was reduced to several feet, yet they continued working without respirators because management assured them the materials were completely safe for handling.
| "What we see repeatedly in Brooklyn Navy Yard cases is that workers had no idea what they were being exposed to. They trusted their employer to provide safe working conditions, and that trust was betrayed. The evidence shows the Navy knew about asbestos dangers but chose to prioritize production over worker safety." |
| — Rod De Llano, Founding Partner, Danziger & De Llano |
The comprehensive contamination throughout the facility meant that even workers who never directly handled asbestos materials faced significant exposure. Administrative workers in offices faced asbestos through ventilation systems that circulated fibers from industrial areas into administrative buildings. Maintenance workers encountered asbestos in building materials throughout the 300-acre complex. Guards patrolling the facility inhaled fibers settling on surfaces throughout the shipyard. The pervasive nature of asbestos contamination at Brooklyn Navy Yard ensured that employment at the facility during the asbestos era, regardless of specific job assignment, created substantial mesothelioma risk.[11]
What Did Dr. Selikoff's Research Reveal About Brooklyn Navy Yard?
Dr. Irving Selikoff's landmark epidemiological studies of Brooklyn Navy Yard workers provided the scientific foundation that revolutionized medical understanding of occupational asbestos disease and established the evidentiary basis for thousands of subsequent legal claims. His prospective mortality study tracked 3,893 workers employed at the facility between 1942 and 1946, following their health outcomes over subsequent decades to document the long-term consequences of wartime asbestos exposure. The study's findings proved devastating, demonstrating health impacts that exceeded even the most pessimistic predictions about asbestos-related disease.[12]
The study documented 11 mesothelioma deaths among the 3,893 tracked workers compared to just 1.5 expected in a comparable general population, representing a 633% increase in this asbestos-signature cancer. This seven-fold elevation in mesothelioma incidence established definitive proof that shipyard asbestos exposure caused the disease, a finding that fundamentally changed both medical science and legal liability standards. Lung cancer deaths reached 89 compared to 55.4 expected, demonstrating substantial excess mortality from this more common malignancy as well. Asbestosis killed workers at rates far exceeding general population expectations, with radiographic evidence of the disease appearing in the majority of long-term workers.[13]
| ℹ Medical Research Milestone: Dr. Selikoff's Brooklyn Navy Yard study became the foundational research establishing the causal link between occupational asbestos exposure and mesothelioma. This research is routinely cited in medical literature and legal proceedings worldwide. |
A 1940 report by a Brooklyn Navy Yard medical officer represents one of the earliest official recognitions of asbestos health hazards in American shipbuilding, yet operations continued unchanged for another 26 years until the shipyard's closure. This internal documentation proved that the Navy possessed knowledge of asbestos dangers decades before workers began developing fatal cancers, establishing the willful negligence that underlies many legal claims. By 1962, when the New York Academy of Sciences held its Conference on the Biological Effects of Asbestos, Brooklyn Navy Yard workers were already dying from exposures that occurred 20 years earlier, yet no protective measures had been implemented at the facility.[14]
Long-term health monitoring revealed that Brooklyn Navy Yard workers continued developing asbestos-related diseases well into the 21st century. A follow-up study conducted in 2009 found that workers were still being diagnosed with mesothelioma 43 years after the shipyard closed, demonstrating the extraordinary latency period of asbestos-related cancers. The New York State Department of Health identified Brooklyn Navy Yard employment as a significant risk factor for mesothelioma in regional cancer surveillance studies, highlighting the facility's ongoing public health impact decades after its closure.
Workers from specific trades showed varying disease rates that reflected their different exposure intensities. Insulators who directly handled asbestos materials experienced mesothelioma at 45 times the expected rate, the highest elevation documented. Pipefitters developed mesothelioma at 20 times expected rates from their extensive work with asbestos-wrapped pipes and gaskets. Even Electricians, whose asbestos contact was largely indirect through working in contaminated environments, experienced mesothelioma at 5 times expected rates, demonstrating that bystander exposure at the facility created substantial disease risk.[15]
How Did Secondary Exposure Affect Brooklyn Families?
Secondary asbestos exposure through contaminated work clothing affected thousands of Brooklyn families who never entered the Navy Yard gates, creating a multi-generational health crisis that continues producing new mesothelioma diagnoses today. Dr. Selikoff's research revealed that 11.3% of shipyard workers' wives showed radiographic evidence of asbestos-related lung changes from their daily exposure to contaminated work clothes. Women who shook out dusty coveralls, washed asbestos-laden clothing in family washing machines, and breathed fibers released during household laundering developed pleural plaques and other asbestos-related conditions at rates that shocked researchers.[16]
Children faced particularly insidious exposure through everyday interactions with their fathers returning from work at the shipyard. Youngsters who hugged fathers still covered in asbestos dust, played with contaminated work boots, or sat on fathers' laps while workers still wore their shipyard clothing inhaled microscopic fibers that lodged permanently in their lung tissue. These childhood exposures manifested as mesothelioma 40 to 60 years later, creating a wave of diagnoses among people who never worked at the facility but whose only exposure came through family contact with Brooklyn Navy Yard workers.
| "Many of the families I work with had no idea that washing dad's work clothes 50 years ago could lead to a mesothelioma diagnosis today. The guilt these family members feel is heartbreaking, but it's so important for them to understand this wasn't their fault. The companies that made these products knew they were dangerous and said nothing." |
| — David Foster, Client Advocate, Danziger & De Llano |
The Brooklyn Navy Yard secondary exposure pattern established crucial legal precedents that enable family members to pursue compensation claims against asbestos manufacturers. Courts recognized that companies which sold asbestos products to the shipyard knew or should have known that workers would carry fibers home to their families, creating foreseeable harm that established legal liability. These take-home exposure cases have resulted in substantial verdicts and settlements for spouses, children, and even grandchildren of Brooklyn Navy Yard workers who developed mesothelioma from household asbestos contact.[17]
The geographic concentration of Navy Yard workers in Brooklyn neighborhoods created community-wide exposure patterns that affected entire streets and apartment buildings. Workers living in housing projects near the shipyard brought asbestos fibers into shared spaces, laundry facilities, and common areas. Neighbors who helped with childcare, visited workers' homes, or shared living spaces faced exposure through environmental contact with contaminated clothing and household surfaces. This community exposure pattern means that mesothelioma diagnoses in Brooklyn often trace back to the Navy Yard even when patients have no direct occupational exposure history.
What Compensation Is Available for Brooklyn Navy Yard Victims?
Workers exposed at Brooklyn Navy Yard and their families have access to multiple compensation pathways that can provide substantial financial recovery for asbestos-related diagnoses. The legal legacy of Brooklyn Navy Yard asbestos exposure established crucial precedents that shaped American tort law and created frameworks specifically designed to compensate shipyard workers and their families. According to Danziger & De Llano case data, recent combined verdicts have reached $104 million for groups of Brooklyn Navy Yard workers, demonstrating courts' continued recognition of corporate liability for these preventable exposures.[18]
| ✓ Good News for Veterans: Navy veterans who worked at Brooklyn Navy Yard automatically qualify for VA disability benefits with ratings up to 100% for mesothelioma diagnoses. VA compensation can be pursued simultaneously with trust fund claims and civil litigation. |
Veterans who served at Brooklyn Navy Yard may qualify for VA disability benefits providing up to $3,737 monthly for 100% disability ratings associated with mesothelioma diagnoses. The VA claims process requires documentation of military service at the shipyard and medical evidence linking disease to asbestos exposure, but the connection between Brooklyn Navy Yard service and subsequent mesothelioma is well-established through decades of medical research. Veterans can receive compensation for their service-connected condition while simultaneously pursuing additional recovery through trust funds and litigation, maximizing total compensation available.[19]
Asbestos trust funds represent another major compensation source for Brooklyn Navy Yard victims. Over 60 active trusts collectively hold more than $30 billion specifically designated to compensate workers exposed to their products. Major trusts with documented Brooklyn Navy Yard exposure include the Johns-Manville Trust ($2.5 billion), Owens Corning Trust ($5.2 billion), and Pittsburgh Corning Trust ($3.8 billion), among many others. Research confirms that individual workers typically qualify for claims against multiple trusts based on exposure to different manufacturers' products during their shipyard employment, with combined trust fund payments often exceeding $400,000.[20]
Civil litigation against companies that continue operating provides another avenue for recovering compensation beyond trust fund payments. Manufacturers that supplied asbestos products to Brooklyn Navy Yard but avoided bankruptcy remain subject to personal injury and wrongful death lawsuits. These cases often proceed to trial or settle for substantial amounts based on evidence showing that companies knew about asbestos dangers but failed to warn workers or provide protective equipment. The landmark federal case In re Brooklyn Navy Yard Asbestos Litigation consolidated hundreds of individual claims and established manufacturer liability standards that continue guiding litigation today.
| Compensation Source | Typical Recovery | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| VA Disability Benefits | Up to $3,737/month | 3-12 months |
| Asbestos Trust Funds | $50,000-$400,000+ combined | 90 days-12 months |
| Civil Litigation | $1-4.5 million average | 12-24 months |
| Combined Recovery | $1-5+ million total | Varies by case |
New York's legal framework provides favorable conditions for Brooklyn Navy Yard claims, including discovery rules that allow expedited proceedings for terminally ill plaintiffs. The New York courts have extensive experience handling asbestos cases from the Brooklyn Navy Yard, with established procedures and precedents that facilitate efficient case resolution. Experienced mesothelioma attorneys familiar with Brooklyn Navy Yard cases can coordinate VA claims, trust fund filings, and litigation simultaneously to maximize recovery while minimizing delays during a patient's illness.[21]
What Is the Brooklyn Navy Yard Site Today?
The Brooklyn Navy Yard site has undergone remarkable transformation from contaminated industrial wasteland to thriving modern manufacturing and creative industry hub, though this redevelopment required extensive environmental remediation that cost millions of dollars and took years to complete. Today's 300-acre Brooklyn Navy Yard Industrial Park houses over 450 businesses and employs approximately 11,000 workers in fields ranging from advanced manufacturing to film production to sustainable technology development. The site's successful redevelopment demonstrates both the massive scope of asbestos remediation required after decades of industrial contamination and the ongoing economic importance of former shipyard properties to American cities.[22]
Modern tenants at the redeveloped facility operate under comprehensive environmental oversight that stands in stark contrast to the complete absence of protection provided to 71,000 World War II workers who handled raw asbestos daily. Current asbestos management protocols include continuous air monitoring, strict containment procedures for any renovation work, and requirements for licensed abatement contractors whenever historic building materials are disturbed. These modern safety measures, mandated by regulations that didn't exist during the shipyard's operational years, prevent new exposures while highlighting the negligence that characterized the facility's historical operations.
New construction projects occasionally encounter previously undiscovered asbestos deposits from the shipyard era, requiring work stoppages and professional remediation before development can continue. The legacy of asbestos contamination embedded in building foundations, soil, and remaining historic structures means that environmental monitoring remains an ongoing requirement for site operations. Despite decades of cleanup efforts, the facility's industrial history continues creating challenges for redevelopment while simultaneously serving as evidence of the pervasive contamination that affected workers for over 60 years.
The human cost of Brooklyn Navy Yard's asbestos use continues accumulating as workers and family members develop diseases from exposures that occurred 40 to 70 years ago. Support groups in the New York metropolitan area specifically serve Brooklyn Navy Yard veterans and their families, providing resources for medical treatment and legal assistance. The shipyard's asbestos legacy affects multiple generations of Brooklyn families who lost fathers to mesothelioma, watched mothers develop asbestosis from washing work clothes, and now face their own disease risks from childhood exposure to contaminated clothing and equipment brought home from the facility.
How Can Victims and Families Get Help?
If you or a family member worked at Brooklyn Navy Yard between the 1930s and 1966, or lived with someone who did, you may have been exposed to asbestos and could be entitled to substantial compensation. The experienced mesothelioma attorneys at Danziger & De Llano have helped thousands of shipyard workers and their families recover compensation through VA benefits, trust fund claims, and litigation against responsible companies. Time limits apply to filing claims, so taking action promptly protects your legal rights and maximizes available recovery options.
|
Free, Confidential Case Evaluation Call (866) 222-9990 or visit dandell.com/contact-us No upfront fees • Experienced representation • National practice |
Related Wiki Articles
Naval Shipyards:
- Norfolk Naval Shipyard
- Portsmouth Naval Shipyard
- Electric Boat
- Long Beach Naval Shipyard
- Hunters Point Naval Shipyard
High-Risk Occupations:
- Insulation Workers
- Boilermakers
- Plumbers and Pipefitters
- Electricians
- Welders
- Marine Engineering Workers
Resources:
References
- ↑ VA Asbestos Exposure, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
- ↑ Mesothelioma Treatment (PDQ), National Cancer Institute
- ↑ Veterans and Mesothelioma Claims, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Asbestos Toxicity: What Is Asbestos?, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR)
- ↑ Mesothelioma Settlements, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Navy Yards and Naval Stations, Naval History and Heritage Command
- ↑ The PACT Act and Your VA Benefits, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
- ↑ Shipyard Workers Mesothelioma Risk, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Asbestos, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- ↑ Learn About Asbestos, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- ↑ Mesothelioma Compensation, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ PubMed - Selikoff Asbestos Studies, National Library of Medicine
- ↑ Cancer Stat Facts: Mesothelioma, NCI Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program
- ↑ History of Asbestos Discovery and Use, National Center for Biotechnology Information
- ↑ Mesothelioma Lawyers, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Current Intelligence Bulletin 62: Asbestos Fibers, CDC/NIOSH
- ↑ Secondary Exposure Legal Rights, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ Mesothelioma Settlements, Danziger & De Llano
- ↑ 2024 VA Disability Compensation Rates, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
- ↑ Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Basics - Asbestos Trusts, United States Courts
- ↑ How to File a VA Disability Claim, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
- ↑ Search Superfund Sites Where You Live, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency